I rarely listen to swing or jazz and have therefore never appreciated mainstream Sinatra. Typically of this musical genre, orchestrations rely heavily on improvisatory jazz harmonics, and the singing often resorts to mauling around the timing and intonation of melodic lines to achieve the signature vocal style. Of course these are the very qualities that many will find so appealing in Sinatra's better known music. This style remains evident in his early melancholy themed compilations with Nelson Riddle such as "In The Wee Small Hours" and "Only The Lonely", and these albums may be preferred by those who enjoy conventional Sinatra.
So why is this album different?
Gone is the 'Come Fly With Me' style. Instead there are lush, soaring string orchestrations (perhaps too schmaltzy for some Sinatra afficionados), which are well suited to this particular programme. Gordon Jenkins seems to have inspired Sinatra to reign back on his excesses of vocal manipulation and improvisation to deliver the tunes in a 'straighter', more melodious style. The gentle frailty and pathos in his vocal timbre, as in the opening lines of 'This Was My Love' (ironically one of Riddle's arrangements!), can't fail to move the listener.
It is one of those rare albums that is consistent throughout, with no need for the'skip' or 'fast-forward' buttons. It is wonderful music for the aching soul - an unashamedly nostalgic wallow that makes for perfect late-night fireside listening.
If I could have just one Sinatra album, then this would be the choice.
For those who enjoy "No One Cares", you will surely also enjoy Sinatra's first collaboration with Gordon Jenkins, "Where Are You", which is in identical style. Also sample the haunting desolation of Sinatra's "A Man Alone" album from 1969 - but lock away the 'sharps' if you are prone to depression!