As of writing, this is the third review for this book and the previous two are not complimentary. Therefore, I want to contribute that I did enjoy reading this book and I think it is written well. Pretty Hate Machine by Daphne Carr is a quality book. However, I can understand the disappointment other reviewers have with the book, as it is annoying to expect one thing and get something else. If you read this book, here is what you will find:
1) An introduction that defines the type of NIN fan of the 1990s.
2) A 19 page explanation of the making of Pretty Hate Machine.
3) A history/analysis of important cities of Trent Reznor's youth, including Mercer, PA, Youngstown, OH, and Cleveland.
4) Testimonials from fans about their lives and the importance of NIN in their journey.
5) A conclusion essay about the connection of NIN recordings with youth culture, particularly Hot Topic.
A common frustration of the 33 1/3 series is that they seem to promise a thorough explanation of how albums are created. However, content can vary widely. Some books deliver and give a thorough account of the album's creation. Other authors only loosely tie the album to their narrative. And others set out to historically document the album, but are frustrated to find they cannot get key players to be interviewed. From the start, Carr states that this book is more about the fans of NIN and Pretty Hate Machine than the band or the album. Having experienced (and enjoyed) this kind of 33 1/3 book before (AC DC's Highway To Hell (33 1/3) and A Tribe Called Quest's People's Instinctive Travels And the Paths of Rhythm (33 1/3)), this different approach did not bother me.
Yes, it would have been interesting to read more in depth explanation of the album's creation (including interviews with Reznor, Chris Vrenna, and Flood), but as one who did not know about the PHM demos, I found what was there to be interesting. I also enjoyed the essays on the cities, but some might find their connection to the music a stretch. (My take on it is that NIN was so different, it is interesting to consider that it did not come from anywhere exotic, but from the American Rust Belt.) Finally, I was initially skeptical of the fan monologues, but found them revealing in their own right. NIN is intense music. And for early fans, it was all yours. Then, suddenly you had to share it with everyone. When I was a kid, I rocked my Nine Inch Nails - Broken T-Shirt (but mine was white) in high school and thought all others were poseurs. Thankfully, as an adult I can appreciate the experiences of others. I disagreed with some of the interpretations of lyrics, but found them compelling none the less. Many of these people have had to deal with some very challenging experiences and that a piece of art served as an anchor for survival is an amazing consideration. As outlined in the introduction of the book, with all the incredibly intense lyrics of NIN, it is a fascinating question of what type of person considers the music entertainment.