John Cornwell's book is superb.It is scrupulously fair and intensely illuminating.He writes as someone very familiar with the catholic world ,but what emerges is a flesh and blood man whose exceptional stature is too great ,too loving ,too intense and sincere for his time ;someone who continually and continuously EVOLVES.
The first part makes a wonderful picture of Newman's early life ,its pains ,loves and successes;the culture around him also comes clear .
For example the whole question of sexuality and the conflict with Kingsley are put into a totally convincing framework .This is not just a biography but a work of art seeing Newman under different lights.
The second part ,detailing the transition to Catholoicism and all it entailed is gripping; and more ,you can feel the struggles he underwent without in any way feeling any whitewash around.
The last part is fairly brief but very moving.The Ambrose St John issue is most intelligently approached and convincingly covered.
This is just what good biography should be ,a means of bringing the subject to life without seeking to prove a point or merely recount facts.
J H Newman seems like a figure who continuously evolved, beyond limited versions of Christianity into something much more universal,more CATHOLIC than ever the Roman catholic church has been; maybe ever .
The book ends with a fair account of what seems to be going on among Roman Catholics to make Newman an authorised saint which to an impartial view feels like an effort to "bottle the wind ".
Maybe the one remark one might question is that of Newman "coming to rest " in the RC Church.It is impossible to think of this spirit not ACTIVE.
But for a compact accurate and loving biography one could not do better.