2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Outspoken critique of 'New Age' thought, 8 Dec 2008
This review is from: New Age and Armageddon: Goddess or the Gurus? - Towards a Feminist Vision of the Future (Paperback)
New Age and Armageddon is the most outspoken critique of some of the less balanced excesses of the New Age to be found anywhere - and perhaps still very timely, with the publication of works such as The Secret now become so popular.
Monica Sjöö was an artist and feminist activist who perhaps is better known for the book she co-authored with Barbara Mor, about the Earth Goddess. This more recent book was written after Sjöö has experienced the double tragedy of losing two sons, one in which she experienced the NDE of her dying boy, the other in which her elder son tried to heal himself with rebirthing techniques.
So from the point of knowing a little about New Age excesses, she should know - her son being told that all he needed was a little positive thinking, and he would miraculously stop killing himself with his cancer.
Sjöö has a lot to say about the type of thinking which declares that if we get cancer/are poor/end up in an ethnic cleansing camp, then these kinds of injustices are all things that we wilfully and wantonly 'wanted' to happen as part of our karma, ignorance or whatever, and social injustices of course, need never be politically challenged.
Sjöö, however, is determined to get to the roots of this kind of thinking, which she first discusses in relation to rebirthing and her son's botched healing. She traces a lot of it back to the channelled works of Blavstsky, Steiner and Alice Bailey, with their Manichaean emphasis on worlds of pure spirit and solar fire where the atom bomb is celebrated as a 'liberating' thing, as opposed to the more inferior creations of earth, matter, or moons and wombs. I do not think it is necessary to buy into the whole 'earth-mother' thing to get something out of this book, though some of what she says can be a healthy enough antidote to some of the thinking that underpins so much of the self-improvement movement, as well as possibly having something to say to astrologers, New Agers and Wiccan Pagans alike.
There is a more Luddite side to her thinking that is less easy to condone, however, and her comments, derived from Michael Shallis on the negative and toxic emanations from all computers does, at times, seem to border on another kind of technophobic extremism that does her greater insights little justice.
It may be possible to pick holes with her scholarship and no doubt this book will be, in time. However, the basic insights Sjöö brings about what to my mind certainly seems to be most unbalanced, to say nothing of being imperialistically arrogant, about New Age writings are as sound criticisms of anything I have ever encountered to date. This book is certainly, also a lot more balanced and even-handed in its criticisms that some of the pamphlets she has written, which do sound a little more extreme in places.
I would strongly recommend this book to anyone who has ever felt the slightest bit uneasy about some of the works, channelled or otherwise, mentioned here, and which she discusses in this book.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No