6 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Excellent pop novel, mediocre "intellectual thriller.", 22 Dec 2002
One of Perez-Reverte's most outstanding characteristics has always been his ability to incorporate academic research and arcane and thought-provoking historical data into an exciting and stimulating historical mystery. In the past, this research has always been an integral part of the novel's structure, and woe be unto the reader who, half-asleep when reading, misses a key detail or fails to note some crucial connection necessary to understanding the conclusion. This novel is different. Though it contains an intellectual mystery, it is also part treasure hunt, love story, character study, and treatise on sexual politics.
Not totally successful on any of these levels, I found the novel entertaining, but lacking those special characteristics which have always made Perez-Reverte's books so mentally engaging. The story is relatively simple. Coy, a seaman who has been suspended for two years because of an accident, begins working for Tanger Soto, a pretty, blonde librarian for the Museo Naval, who has purchased a maritime atlas which will help her to locate a sunken ship. The ship, owned by the Jesuits, sank in 1767, and Tanger believes it carries a treasure, which she intends to find. Predictable complications ensue.
The plot divides into two parts--the first part is exciting and full of action as Coy and Tanger launch their search, while the second part is almost dead, as their rivals for the treasure disappear for almost 200 pages. Perez-Reverte tries to keep the excitement going by having a particularly nasty rival reappear, menacingly, from time to time on shore, but eventually the author has to resort to the cute trick of introducing a completely new character, the narrator, to juice up the narrative and the search for the sunken ship. Even the foreshadowing is often heavy-handed: "He suspected that later...he would need to remember something about this place." Tanger, the "love interest," is distant and duplicitous, and Coy is warned by virtually everyone in the book that she can't be trusted, something that prevents the reader from being caught up in the love story. All in all, I found this below Perez-Reverte's past accomplishments, both in story and in execution, entertaining enough, but not the intellectual thriller I expected. Mary Whipple
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
14 of 15 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Excellent, but not his best, 29 April 2002
By A Customer
During and immediately after reading this new book from the Spanish master, I felt that it was something of a departure. It felt more like a "relationship" novel, with adventure woven into it to keep things interesting. Thinking a bit more about it, I decided that the relationship between Coy, our hero, and the female lead, Tanger Soto, was actually only a handy means of bringing out more depth from Coy's character. In this respect, the book is in the end not that much of a remove - it is really very close in nature, although considerably longer than, The Fencing Master.
I would take rate both The Fencing Master and The Seville Communion - a pair of masterpieces in my opinion - ahead of The Nautical Chart, primarily because the plots of both were superior in depth and sheer devilment. The Nautical Chart's plot is thinner and in many ways implausible, but it is all a means to an end - that end being the deep and beautifully drawn exploration of the grounded sailor Coy.
Translation always makes a true estimate of the original work very difficult, but the prose in this version is gorgeous. The character list is very short for a novel of this length, so it needs to be.
In summary, I thoroughly enjoyed The Nautical Chart, but I would not say it was Perez-Reverte's best work.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
8 of 9 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
excellent seafaring adventure, 22 Dec 2002
Just as the technical detail in The Fencing Master reserected my interest in Fencing, the suberb technical detail in The Nautical Chart has awoken a dormant interest in nautical maps and sextants! The gripping story line with its middle-aged hero and young, beautiful heroine/villain (a well proven receipe for Arturo fiction) simply pulls you into the story; you literally feel part of the tale. I've now read the full series of from this Author, and am hungry for more.
My only disappointment is that unlike the previous books, this translation is in american English.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No