Natural Ordermage is L. E. Modesitt's best Recluce novel in a number of years. The combination of a more interesting hero, exploration of a new land and culture, and a slightly different twist on the superhero-awakening plot give a breath of fresh air to a series badly in need of it. I take a half star off for his attempts at romance and his less than thorough exploration of the culture of Hamor, but round it up to 5 stars for a hopeful return to what made the early Recluce novels some of the most interesting in recent memory.
The Magic of Recluce series has fallen victim to Modesitt's quantity-versus-quality mentality; many of the recent additions have been the same formula - young mage comes of age, becomes the most powerful person in the world, makes sacrifices, and becomes the leader of his country after wiping out the bad guys - used over and over. As a result, the series has suffered to the point where some entries in it were nearly unreadable. Of the recent novels, only Wellspring of Chaos and Chaos Balance offered some hope, but in general there hasn't been a spellbinding Recluce novel in the better part of a decade.
Natural Ordermage may not be spellbinding, but it's decent reading. The young-hero-awakening story receives a major shot in the arm with Rahl, a powerful mage-in-the-making who acts a lot more like the spoiled teenager that he is than the typical Modesitt saint-in-training. Rahl is not above using his powers to seduce local girls, and when he doesn't get his own way he turns sullen. This gets him into a whole lot of trouble, some of which isn't his own making, and through a series of bad luck and bad decisions he ends up being exiled to Hamor.
This is the second reason why Natural Ordermage is the best entry in the series in some time; Rahl's exploration of the culture and politics of Hamor is well done, and while Modesitt did something similar by introducing new cultures in Wellspring the Hamorian civilization in Ordermage is much better fleshed out. Another advantage over previous novels is that he doesn't put Rahl at the top of Hamorian society immediately. Rahl may be young and powerful, but without giving away too much of the plot he's got a long way to go at the end of the book. (For now, at least; somehow one strongly suspects that this is the Hamorian dangergelder referred to in an earlier book.)
A half star off for Modesitt's attempt at romance being done as poorly as usual, although one reason the book may be better than many of his recent ones is that that angle is largely absent for most of it. Another slight negative is a bit more unusual: Modesitt doesn't really argue the morality of Hamorian society as he usually does with his characters, but perhaps that will come in a sequel. An upside to this latter issue is that since the protagonist hasn't come to the conclusion that all above him are corrupt, he hasn't yet decided to change the world by lopping off the heads of his bosses, which is a newer plot for Modesitt.
For now, 5 stars and one of the few Modesitt novels of recent years worth reading.