Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
6 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A Mesmerising Study in Isolation and Human Relationships, 1 Sep 2008
Naked hit me like a sledgehammer when I first saw it. Unmatched in intensity, it examines several lives in different degrees of detail with one thing in common. They are all alone - even the girls who share the flat and the rich City boy with his girlfriends and conquests. Johnny links them together - his interactions with them, at times gentle, at times vicious and vile. We see, through excellence of acting and writing which is taut but often exuberant, how the morass of London isolates as often as it brings together.
This is a true London film, made up mostly of non-Londonders. It shines a light onto people living in the early 90s, recession-hit, post-Thatcher period. It is a political film, polemical and angry. Johnny is seemingly full of wonder at the world, railing against the 'me, now' generation, and yet deeply cynical about the purpose of existence.
Mike Leigh was accused of being misanthropic with Naked, focusing on the worst of human nature. But you can take from it what you want - in some people's lives there is little or no redemption, but there are moments. Moments of joy, kindness, laughter - even among the despair. You can take the great lines, the arguments, the speeches, the quotations. Take the fact that your life might have gone down the route of many of those people, but didn't. If it sounds like I treated this film like a religious experience, for many years I did. It is beautiful and powerful, rich and epic in its themes. I've never seen another film that spoke more to me about people.
|
|
|
2 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Mike Leigh's finest, 18 Nov 2008
This Mike Leigh film is outstanding! I believe it was nominated for several awards at the Cannes film festival, and rightly so. David Thewlis plays Johnny, a complex anti-hero, which you love and loath in equal quantities. The dialogue is hilarious, witty, condescending and at times just plain mean.
The standout scene for me is when Johnny is invited into a security unit by a guard out of sympathy. Johnny then proceeds to destroy this poor man's hopes and dreams with a scathing philosophical monologue about our future as a human race. The supporting cast are equally good, in particular Greg Cruttwell as the nihilistic, vain and deeply shallow landlord. The music score is eerily compelling and haunting , and fits perfectly with the characters and scenery.
Unfortuntly Leigh hasn't made anything this dark or disturbing before or since. However he's still more consistent than most directors, and has become somewhat of a master at making thought provoking films.
|
|
|
1 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
"You can't make an omlette without cracking a few eggs, and humanity is just a cracked egg"., 27 Nov 2008
I watched this film because I always enjoy David Thewlis' performances - and I was surprised that this Mike Leigh film had passed me by. It focuses on the lives of two men, two men who are in many ways hideous examples of masculinity (abusing women in various ways) though the middle class Jeremy (Greg Cruttwell) is a psychopath with no likable traits, whereas Johnny (Thewlis) is a tormented tormentor - a vagabond with intellect. One man feels very much part of a doomed humanity. The other hates it and enjoys controlling it through cruelty and violence.
This isn't a particularly structured film - more a series of moments which don't necessarily contribute to a plot, but instead open up the characters. Thewlis steals the show with what must be one of the greatest screen performances ever, as he mingles with the guts of society. Every comment he utters is laced with either wit, vitriol, or the musings of a man who seems to enjoy the world when it's ugly. Imagine a homeless, bitter Oscar Wilde and it's not a million miles away from Johnny.
It's difficult to describe this film - there's so much going on without there being much ...well, going on! You get to see the fragility of relationships and nobody seems to benefit, certainly not the people you want to see come out on top.
In a nutshell: A dark film where lives are turned upside down. When the credits roll you don't really know if the characters will ever get a happy ending or the justice they deserve. This film is worth watching purely on the strength of David Thewlis alone. Without him this would be a three star film for me. His lamented genius is mesmerising to watch as he walks around philosophising, like an anti-Jesus preaching the gospel of not looking on the bright side.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|