Most Helpful Customer Reviews
14 of 14 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Heartbreak River, 9 Sep 2006
I bought the video of 'Mystic River' and was two thirds of the way through when I decided that I would read the book before I saw the end of the movie. And I really wanted to see the end...
So I read the book over four nights, and was surprised at just how closely the film version was sticking to the story. (A very rare event.) Certain details were changed - Jimmy has fair hair, Katie has blonde hair - minor stuff I know, but significant when you are visualising characters in a novel. And there were an extra few plot strands, of course.
The strengths of the novel originate in Dennis Lehane's authorial voice.He seems to be able to articulate despair and grief, to cut to the quick of things, with great honesty and perception. A case in point is Dave Boyle's remembering of his mother singing 'Old Macdonald' to him after he returns from the most traumatic experience possible, and his caustic, heartbroken commentary on it.
Apart from all the harsh questions 'Mystic River' raises, especially during its harrowing closing chapters, it is also a great read. A crime thriller which genuinely thrills. Lehane gets everything right in this department.
After closing the book I also felt I had read a great American novel. A novel of stature, up there with Steinbeck and Heller and Doctorow.
And when I watched the ending of the film I was surprised not only at how close it still kept to the novel - Brian Hegeland's script has used the engine of the book to great effect - but just how much Clint Eastwood had captured the atmosphere. And how perfect the casting was. A double whammy. Perfect book and perfect film.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
12 of 12 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A Great American Novel Noir Becomes A New Classic!, 19 Feb 2005
Dennis Lehane is a master at creating mood. With "Mystic River" he paints a portrait of a bleak working class neighborhood, Boston's East Buckingham Flats, and its inhabitants, who are doomed to spend generations stuck in the dark, brooding environment, just a breath away from exploding into violence. I used to think of Dennis Lehane as an excellent writer of mysteries. After reading "Mystic River," I consider him to be one of America's great new literary novelists. His characters are real, rich and complex; his dialogue is as true as the characters who speak it. The narrative is spare and elegant. And the plot is edge-of-your-seat suspenseful, always developing a new twist. The book opens with three angry eleven year-old boys, Jimmy Marcus, Sean Devine and David Boyle, pushing each other around on one of the neighborhood streets. A car pulls up and two, (apparently) plain clothes cops aggressively order David into their car. Terrified, David admits he doesn't live on that street. One man says they're going to drive Dave home and tell his Mom he's been fighting. Then the three drive away, leaving the other two boys with sick feelings in their guts. These feelings of fear, and something gone terribly awry, will remain with them all their lives. The two men were not cops. And Dave never reaches his mother that day, nor for many days afterward. This incident will link the lives, and the destinies, of these three boys forever. Twenty-five years have passed, and the boys are men now, living in the same neighborhood, not far from where they spent their childhood. The events of a seemingly innocent Saturday night on the town, turn violent. Murder most vicious is the outcome, and it brings all three, inextricably, back together. This tale of friendship, family, loyalty and revenge is just plain brilliant in its intensity. The unsettled feelings the novel evoked in me, stayed with me for days after I completed it. This is one of the best, well-crafted novels I have read in a very long time. Kudos to Dennis Lehane! JANA
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
7 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
MYSTIC RIVER, 16 Oct 2005
I'd had 'MYSTIC RIVER' on my wish list for ages but did not actually purcahse it until I heard that they were turning it itno a movie staring Sean Penn and Kevin Bacon. While I heard great things anout Dennis Lehane as an author this was the firsrt of his books that I've read and I am very pleased that I chose this one to start with. Lehane paints a picture so realistically that you can alomst feel the grief, anger and despair that his characters feel. Jimmy, Davey and Sean were childhood friends and while all very different in personality, Jimmy being the tough one, Sean the boy from the "right side of the tracks" and Davey the follower, they never missed a Saturday together. However, one Saturday things take a turn for the unexpected when two men posing as police officers abduct Davey. Once returned to his familly days later and knowing the horrors that Davey must have enduredd at the hands of these men, the friendship between the three boys is irrevocably torn. Twenty some odd years later, when Jimmy's daughter Kaite is murdered the three of them are thrown back into each others lives. Sean is the investigating officer in Katie's murder and Davey who is married to Jimmy's wife's cousin is there to lend his support. But with a secret hanging over his head about his own misdeeds the night of Katie's murder Davey must try to keep it together himself. When young Davey is abducted in the first few chapters of the book you feel the anguish that his family and friends go through as they await his safe return. You can also feel how tourtured that experience has left Davey as an adult. When Jimmy's daughter is murdered you feel the pain and sadness that he and his family go through and understand his urge to find the killer and make him pay at any cost. And when Sean is forced to investigate the murder of his estranged friends daughter you can feel how torn he is between doing his job and a sense of loyalty to an old firend in the hardest time of his life. After reading 'MYSTIC RIVER' I couldn't wait to see how this story played out on the big screen and for once the movie stayted very true to the book. Penn and Robin's performances were defintiley Oscar worthy as you see these characters brought to life. If you loved the movie you will love this book even more.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|