I have heard people describe this as 500 pages of boredom with nearly 200 pages of excitement, but thast isn't really true. After the success of her previous novel Ann Radcliffe was paid a whopping £500 for this, which is her largest novel, and is nowadays her most famous, mainly due to its being mentioned in Northanger Abbey.
It could be argued that this is too big and baggy, but if it was 'tightened' up it would inevitable lose something. As for its being gothic, like her first novel this is gothic in places, but contains so much more. Apart from the gothic element you have romance, adventure, a thriller, a mystery, some humour, and so much more. There is a supernatural element, but those who know Radcliffe's works will know that apart from her last novel which was published posthumously, all supernatural elements are eventually explained, also there is a locked room mystery here as well. I know that her husband was scared to read this book alone, I don't know however if it was just this novel, or other works of hers as well. Today of course it isn't scary, but with a brilliant use of cliffhangers and other hooks this is something that is full of suspense, and is fun to read. Ultimately this novel cannot be explained fully enough to do it justice, which is one of the things that have kept people coming back to it time and time again. The narrative pace is a bit slow in places, and also there is quite a lot of poetry here, but don't let that put you off. Currently I am working my way through all Radcliffe's novels, both those I have read before and those that I am coming to for the first time. After reading this you will like me, always have a copy on your bookshelf.