Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
13 of 13 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
The gothic tradition and more., 11 Aug 2001
By A Customer
Characters,particularly female ones, tend to be rather flat and anaemic. Radcliffe concentrates on powerful male figures, the dark menace of Montoni or the benevolent paternity of St. Aubert and the Count de Villefois. Descriptions of France and Italy are painterly and will have you rushing to book a flight to the Languedoc or somewhere near the Appenines. It could be said, perhaps, that the landscapes are the real protagonists in the tale. Radcliffe skilfully ties up all the lose threads but the explanations given of supernatural events are highly improbable. Pivotal theme of the work could be said to be 'Fortitude' and how Emily, the heroine,finds and develops this quality in herself. Worth reading,not only because it is regarded as the seminal gothic novel, but because it was instrumental in raising the status of novel writing in the eyes of the literary establishment. This enabled female novel writers to gain credibility and acceptance whereas until this point,poetry writing,predominantly the province of men,was seen as weightier and cerebral in comparison to the trifling shallowness of novels.
|
|
|
23 of 26 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Just plain good fun!, 12 Feb 2005
I came to this book after reading about it in Jane Austen's 'Northanger Abbey', which I suspect is why many enquirers are now reading this! I really enjoyed it and, although some of the other reviewers' negative comments are at least partly justified, I'd say, if you're not afraid of long novels, give it a go, it's just good fun.By 21st century standards of horror, this story is tame and childish, but if you're like me and don't appreciate the excesses of modern horror and supernatural/occult things, but just enjoy a good read, you'll find this more to your taste. Yeah, sure there are some unbelievable parts, (like Emily's being able to compose whole sonnets on the spot, for one), but fiction like this is not really meant to be convincing. Mrs Radcliffe wrote to entertain the masses, and that's what she achieves. Yes, the desciptions can be a bit tedious at times, but if you read quickly as most of us do when we're 'in to' a novel, they soon pass and you get on with the story. I esp. liked the fact that all the mysteries are explained in the end which saves you from having to go through the dissatisfying experience of wanting to know exactly what happened back there when 'x' did 'y' and so on, but never being told. (I sometimes wonder if some authors couldn't think of anything convincing with which to tie up their loose ends!!) Have fun!=)
|
|
|
5 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Delightful, over-the-top mystery, 8 Nov 1998
By A Customer
If you like your villains dastardly, your heroines swooning, and your castles brooding, this is the book for you! Our heroine is Emily St Aubert, whom we follow through family tragedy, romance, and exploitation. Murder, war, brigandry, and coincidence are thrown in for good measure. Some readers may dislike Emily's character - she weeps and swoons a great deal, and is largely passive in the face of malevolence.Those who like their stories 'lean and mean' will find this a lot to digest at almost seven hundred pages, and the pace is often ponderous, with the early parts of the book largely a travelogue through 16th century France and Italy. Here there is a lot of repetition about the sublimity and awfulness (as in inspiring awe) of nature. The poems, which are liberally sprinkled throughout the book, are best skipped. But despite these criticisms, this is a hugely entertaining book. Radcliffe's descriptions provide wonderful atmosphere, producing an almost dreamlike feel whether in a gloomy castle or on a summer walk. The characters are strongly defined, and their emotions palpable. Highly recommended.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|