I was reluctant to write this review, because I'm a huge fan of Lipman's novels and, as I have written elsewhere, think "The Inn at Lake Devine" was one of the best novels of the last decade of the 20th century. Furthermore, I was excited about the premise of this novel, the "Eloise of a women's college" idea.
The plot is thin. Frederica is the child of the Marshalsea (an obvious allusion Lipman misses) for a women's college in Brookline, Mass. Her parents are faculty members who have served as house parents since before she was born; they have no car, and fight the school administration as union activists. Into their lives comes Laura Lee French, who turns out to be David Hatch's ex-wife and cousin, of whose existence Frederica was entirely unaware. Then Laura Lee becomes a house mother on campus, and seduces the new president of the college, causing his wife to attempt suicide and become an invalid. During the great snow of 1978, the plot resolves.
There are good things here. The character of Frederica herself is interesting and charming. The conflict between her labor agitator parents and the anachronistic women's college (formerly a secretarial school) in the late 70's, rings true. So too are the glimpses we see of Frederica's social life, such as it was, at Brookline High School, and the obvious limitations caused by living on a college campus and having parents who don't own a car. The best part of the book was the allegedly democratic way in which Frederica is raised, which is a transparent means by which her parents, and her mother in particular, manipulate her.
The main problem I had with the book was with the engine for the plot, her father's ex-wife and cousin Laura Lee French. To me, Laura Lee enters the novel with the label "literary device" so firmly attached to her forehead I couldn't see past it. Laura Lee, it turns out, is the cause of the family's living on campus, because she has been living off David's alimony since he left her for Aviva, Frederica's mom. David's mother has always preferred her to Aviva. Her own mother and David's mother are close. Yet somehow her very existence was hidden from Frederica for all those years, years during which, it would seem to me, liberal labor activists' views on divorce would have gone through such a transformation as to make the entire story trivial to their daughter. Instead, it is treated like a state secret, making Laura Lee's advent at the college even more of a temptation to Frederica.
The other thing that bothered me about this book is that people always seem to be talking in speeches, not dialogue, and they tend to share what I think were unlikely views of marriage, divorce and sex for the time and the place (in the interests of full disclosure, I was living about five miles away at the time the book took place). Where is the person to say "divorce? who cares?" or "so they're sleeping together, big deal?" This was 1978, the eye of the hurricane between the advent of the pill and the discovery of HIV, the one real time where free love seemed to have no consequences. This book takes place in a women's college in one of the most liberal towns in America at exactly this moment in history, and (despite the hints about what the students themselves are doing), I simply don't recognize the time or the place in this novel.