I got "100 Must-Read Fantasy Novels" last Saturday and spent the rest of the weekend deriving great pleasure from reading Nick Rennison & Stephen E. Andrew's excellent choices within. As Mr Andrews says in his introduction, it isn't a list of the 100 best or the 100 greatest or the 100 most literary or even (that dreaded catch-all) '100 favourite' fantasy novels; but rather a selection of fantasy novels that any discerning reader ought to be familiar with.
As lists go, although I've not been a huge reader of fantasy novels since my teens, I honestly couldn't disagree with any of the authors' selections. Some are great, some are mediocre but all have a significance that makes them required reading. A particular novel might not have any great literary or artistic merit but its significance in the field of fantasy literature can't be ignored nor underestimated and so it's entirely proper that it should be included as a 'must-read' book. (And no, I'm not talking about "Eragon"!)
Neither do Messrs Rennison & Andrews restrict their definition of 'fantasy' to just Tolkien-esque Orcs and Elves but rather spread their net further afield to include novels without obvious fantasy tropes but which nonetheless embrace 'The Fantastical' - in much the same way that Michael Moorcock and James Cawthorne did in "Fantasy: The 100 Best Books" - although Messrs Rennison & Andrews' selection is better focused on the casual fantasy (or non-fantasy) reader than Messrs Moorcock & Cawthorne's 1988 text, which now feels a little archaic and esoteric in its choices. The present authors also score highly by selecting titles that are easy for the reader to get hold of, since there's no point recommending books which will then prove next-to-impossible to acquire.
In addition to the main list of 100 Must-Read fantasy novels, the authors provide 'Read on' recommendations for each of their selections (a kind of 'if you loved that you'll like this' thing) thus expanding the choice of material for the reader by some additional 400 titles, thus providing a well-rounded reading experience.
All in all, I can't recommend this book too highly for anyone who wants to explore the world of The Fantastical - whether they're a newcomer or veteran to the world of Fantasy - and is looking for a knowledgeable and dependable guide to steer their path. In that respect, Nick Rennison and Stephen E. Andrews are your men.