This is an excellent and must-read book especially for music teachers interested in exploring and challenging alternate avenues for musical learning. The book is really a case study conducted in Great Britain where high school general music classes were given instruments without instruction, and asked to simply 'figure out' how to play the student selected songs. The findings of this study are amazing and very insightful especially in regards to how people approach and learn music when left to their own devices. This book isn't an advocacy for a particular methodology, and even Green agrees that the methods used in the case study would be too extreme as a standard generalized approach, but it does offer quite a lot of insight that challenges many of our assumes in regards to traditional general music approaches. And for those people weary of case studies filled with mind-numbing statistical, this book rightly avoids drowning the reading with endless numbers. Much of the findings are based on personal interviews with the teachers and students who partook in the study.