With the arrival of Giuliano Carmignola's new Archiv version of these concertos (July 2008), it is time for some reappraisal. How does this 1990 recording by Simon Standage fare in comparison? There is precious little to choose between them in terms of price, and Standage is always worth taking into account, especially if, like me, you feel that the other contenders - Anne-Sophie Mutter et al - create a sound that is too warm and 'Romantic'.
Although Standage is admirably restrained here, his tone being undemonstratively cool, the presentation of these youthful pieces does seem to lack a certain energy and dynamism. The AAM under Christopher Hogwood, while proving as competent as ever, offer little to relieve the sensation of anaemia. The overall effect is too unadventurous, too muted, too pallid. The cadenza of Concerto 4's Rondeau features a provocative little slide while that of Concerto 3 has arabesques elaborating over the orchestra's refrain. Such injections of colour, however, are too rare.
Generally, the cadenzas are lacklustre - and the booklet doesn't help by omitting to identify them. Its brief notes do, however, provide a quotation from a letter by Wolfgang to Leopold: 'You know I am no lover of difficulties.' (This, presumably, to justify the restrained, un-pyrotechnical performance style.) Ultimately and unfortunately, we've no way of knowing exactly whose style or tempi their composer would have preferred, or even whether he would have advocated original or modern instruments. One thing is questionable, however: in what sense is a violin made in 1987 'authentic'? Modelled on a violin by Stradivarius - 'The Dancla' of 1703, apparently - one wonders just how close a match the new version is to the old in terms of its essential quality: sound.
So times move on. Although I could easily live with these performances by an outstanding violinist, Carmignola's new CD would have to be the recommendation - especially so given its 'bonus' material, the wonderfully dramatic Sinfonia Concertante for violin and viola, K364.