Nikolaus Harnoncourt brings all the sensitivity of his historically informed approach to the orchestra pit. Heading a very strong cast are Rodney Gilfry, defiantly strong-voiced but also haughtily handsome as the seducing Don, and Cecilia Bartoli, a mercurial presence as Donna Elvira. Their scenes together crackle and fizz, even when Bartolis extremely ripe vibrato contrasts a little uncomfortably with Harnoncourts authenticity. Liliana Nikiteanu makes for a pretty, naïve Zerlina, convincingly torn between her Masetto (Oliver Widmer) and the animalistic attraction of the Don. Laszlo Polgars Leporello is wheedling and base, but still the inheritor of his masters charisma; Isabel Rey and Roberto Sacca are solid as the colourless moralists Anna and Ottavio; while Matti Salminens powerful Commendatore isnt expected to do anything more than stand still and declaim. Overall this is an excellent musical performance, unexceptionally staged.
On the DVD: Don Giovanni on disc has a good 24-minute "Behind the Scenes" feature, including interviews with Cecilia Bartoli, Harnoncourt, Gilfry and Isabel Rey. Theres also a trailer for other ArtHaus releases. The 16:9 picture sometimes struggles to bring definition to the dimly lit sets; sound though is crisp and clean PCM stereo or Dolby 5.1. There are subtitles in five languages. --Mark Walker
Wonderful music, great conductor, great orchestra, great voices and great performance! Did meet every expectation, my recomendation for newbies and connaisseurs.Published 20 months ago by Tamara Jagellovsk
This is a very good Don Giovanni with darkness interwoven with light humour. Bartoli sometimes is a little over the top in her role as Donna Elvira. Read morePublished on 15 Feb. 2008 by Aquinas
I think this comment just about sums it up.
For me Cicilia Bartoli can do no wrong ... you must see her in La Chenorentola!!! Read more
To be honest, I really don't like this production. At all. The sets were poor and jarred with the opera itself (Why was there a backdrop of river boats in the scene where the... Read morePublished on 28 Jan. 2006
This production is not too successful. It surprised me, because I thought Rodney Gilfry would be such an obvious Don Giovanni. Read morePublished on 18 April 2005 by Christian Aalling