I bought this album on the strength of the reviews of other Amazon users, thinking it would be interesting to hear the Nephilim's long-awaited new material. I wanted to like this album but after several playings, I've passed it on. It is pretty much accepted that "Elizium" was the band's masterpiece and following it up -especially ten years later - was never going to be easy. But all we are given is a collection of songs that could have been on "Elizium" were it not for their sub-standard quality. Whereas the songs on "Elizium" were well crafted, achingly beautiful sound-scapes, these songs lack structure and tell us nothing we don't know already. "Shroud" opens the album but is it an intro like "Dead but Dreaming" or is it a fully-fledged song? Who knows? "Straight to the Light" raises the bar slightly but then the comparisons to "For Her Light" come in. Because it was so poor, I found "New Gold Dawn" pretty hard to listen to and always skipped on to "Requiem," which could have been called "At the Gates of Silent Memory 2." "Xiberia" is a much stronger effort and actually takes you in a new direction with its looped synth lines and bonkers drumming. "She" again lacks any coherent structure and goes on far too long and the title track seems like an afterthought. The real highlight of the whole collection is "In the Year 2525," which rivals the likes of Joe Cocker's version of With a Little Help From My Friends as being one of the best cover versions of all time. The album's production is what lets it down. Again, comparisons with "Elizium" are inevitable. That album is one of the best produced albums ever. Mourning sun is saturated by over production to the extent that Nod Wright's new drumming style was all but inaudible. If you've never heard any FOTN before don't buy this. Buy "Elizium" instead and prepare to have your life changed. If you're a hardcore FOTN fan you'll probably love "Mourning Sun" anyway, rendering this review irrelevant.