Motty: Forty Years in the Commentary Box [Hardcover]

 

 

Create your own review

John Motson, in common with all good broadcasters, prepares assiduously for the live commentary. The two page example of his work in the second set of illustrations (Barnsley versus Chelsea FA Cup replay) shows just how much work goes into making a live football game run smoothly on air. I wish I could say as much for this book which proves how right Motson was to opt for radio and television work rather than print journalism.

Motson had a good reputation as a television commentator although it wasn't one I shared as a television watcher. Brian Clough sussed him out in an early interview when he accused a disconcerted Motson of lecturing to Match of the Day audiences rather than letting the game speak for itself in the action. In fact, Motson is appreciative of Clough's direct approach and provides him and his sidekick, Peter Taylor, with a complete chapter of their own. He records with sadness Clough's decline into alcoholism but remains unconvinced that he would have succeeded as England manager.

Motson comments on the various managers employed by England over the years rating Sir Alf Ramsay and Sven Goran Eriksson first and third, split only by Bobby Robson. I find his choice of Eriksson in the top three surprising. When England played ten man Brazil at the World Cup Eriksson's lack of tactical awareness was embarrassing to watch. His choice of the inexperienced and untried Theo Walcott for the 2006 World Cup was disastrous. Although short of strikers Walcott never got a game. Eriksson, as with his response to the failure against Brazil, was too stubborn to admit he got it wrong. He was successful in Italy but a failure in England and was not helped by being talked up by the inadequate players he selected for the national team.

Motson correctly identifies one of the main problems of England's underperforming overpaid soccer players. Many of them succeed at club level but lack the mental strength to reproduce it on the international stage. This was immediately recognised by Fabio Capello who appreciates playing for a purpose is an integral part of the game. Viewing a video of Steve McClaran's last game against Croatia the Italian asked the F A's Brian Barwick why England were attacking at two, two, given that a draw would have seen England through. Of course, the England managers Motson has seen include three people who later admitted they weren't up to the job, Kevin Keegan, Graham Taylor and McClaren. The others were the over-rated pair of Venables and Hoddle, Ron Greenwood who was too old to provide the dynamism required for the 1982 World Cup but fitted in well with the blazered brigade and Don Revie who was something of an enigma. Little wonder England failed to win anything.

Motson is a critic of the influence of money in the game but not the foreign players imported by the Premier League. He's highly critical of debt levels and the gap developing between the Big Four and the rest of the League (although the challenge to the Big Four is funded by rich investors) . He holds far from fashionable views on subjects such as the Champions League and would prefer a win on points in drawn matches rather than penalty shoot outs, even at the expense of extra time. The game is run by television and, although he was part of that, albeit at a distance from Sky's selfish coverage, he appears to share the view of his nemesis Clough that there is too much football on television.

One area in which Motson succeeds is that of appreciating that for many years he had to battle with Barry Davies for the commentating position at major games. Despite all his disappointments he decided to remain loyal to the BBC when ITV offered him the opportunity to jump ship. There's a number of incidents revealing how easy it is to commit a faux par (known in the business as Colemanballs) most of them relating to asking managers stupid questions in the aftermath of a game. My own all time favourite is David Coleman's question to Don Fox, who had missed a conversion in front of the posts which would have won his team the Rugby League Cup. The athlete Steve Ovett boycotted post race interviews for many years to avoid such questions.

Motson reveals quite a bit about his background as the son of a Methodist minister but very little about his home life. His wife and son get barely twenty mentions in the entire book. It can be argued that as the book is about his four decades in the commentary box such scant reference to the family is only to be expected. That's a fair point but it leaves Motson's book somewhat imbalanced, notwithstanding his many stories of human kindness. Motson does reveal(as many will have forgotten) that he covered others sports, including tennis, during his forty year career. It's not a bad book but not one I would instantly recommend. Writing should flow, Motson's stagnates. Three stars.

Had this book sent direct as birthday present for 30+ year old son who is avid Liverpool supporter. He has grown up listening to Motty commentate on matches and couldnt believe my great choice. He was well chuffed to receive it, and says it is a brill read as well as a momento on a great commentator!!

It's a refreshing change to find not only a biography of someone who is firstly, an expert in their field; secondly, has a long career at the top of their profession and, most importantly, can actually write. That John Motson started work in print journalism has stood him in good stead here. Motty is a highly entertaining mixture of nostalgia, insight and comment on the modern game. Unlike other reviewers, I didn't find the statistics at the end boring, but a memory-jogger of games I had been at or remember from Match of the Days past. This will be dipped into long after ghost-written hagiographies of today's cosseted players have been consigned to the charity shop.

Share your thoughts with other customers: Create your own review

› See all 11 customer reviews...

 

3.0 out of 5 stars Interesting!
Good book especially if you are a football enthusiast. Motty uncovers loads of interesting facts.

Published 18 months ago

5.0 out of 5 stars Motty's 40 years in the commentary box
This book was bought as a birthday present. It arrived quickly, well packaged. The recipient was delighted with his gift!

Published 18 months ago by gynohtna

1.0 out of 5 stars Motty - 40 years of claptrap
What a waste of my time reading this poor excuse of a biography. During radio advertisements the book is portrayed as a book which describes "Motty's" thoughts on the best teams... Read more

Published on 5 Jan 2010 by Mrs. C. Doyle

3.0 out of 5 stars A fine commentator but a tame autobiography
John Motson has a bit of an image problem. Many people see him as a `train-spotter' type of person, with a head full of football statistics rather than the numbers of the rolling... Read more

Published on 27 Nov 2009 by Bantam Dave

1.0 out of 5 stars Yawn! Is it half time yet?!
I once met Motty, and it's vaguely reassuring to discover his book is as boring and limp-wristed as he is in the flesh! It was like shaking hands with a dead trout! Read more

Published on 27 Nov 2009 by Royale

5.0 out of 5 stars The voice of Football tells all
Motty is a legend in our house and his autobiography is a cracking read - from that goal by Ricky Villa in the 1981 FA Cup final to his legendary bon MOTS - 'for those watching in... Read more

Published on 2 Nov 2009 by Edmund

1.0 out of 5 stars Very, Very Dull
I might be missing something but what a load of old rubbish this book is. I gave it two x 20 page chapters before finally having to give up. Read more

Published on 23 Oct 2009 by Mr. S. Hammond

3.0 out of 5 stars EVERYTHING PLUS A SHEEPSKIN COAT !
Just the read to bring to bed on a cold winter night with "Motty" whispering his dulcet tones in your ear and telling you tales from "AUNTIE'S BOUDOIR"

Published on 15 Oct 2009 by Peter Hughes

Search Customer Reviews
Only search this product's reviews

› See all 11 customer reviews...

Search Listmania!