Its a tough job turning such a diverse album into a tribute that works. However, since the songs on Oar often sound like unfinished sketches of songs, its nice to see what such a varied bunch of musos do with them. Little Hands is one of Robert Plant's more controlled performances - its whispered delivery suits the themes of the song nicely. Elsewhere, Book of Moses is such a good song for Tom Waits, it is almost impossible to believe he didn't write it. Some songs won't be for everyone - the Ophelias do what they can with Lawrence of Euphoria, which again suits their oddball charm. But you do feel that some of the bands get a raw deal in the carve up of songs, as Oar has always contained some clunkers. Overall, it doesn't really gel into a great album, or reflect the fragile genius of Skippy's album.