The Roches' first album as a trio in over a decade (baby sis Terre having gone mysteriously AWOL following 1995's Can We Go Home Now) is a triumph. Though all three sisters continued to make beautiful music in solo albums, projects with other musicians, and in particular Suzzy and Maggie's "Zero Church" and "Why the Long Face" albums, for those of us who have loved the Roches since their 1978 eponymous debut album, they all smelled like side projects. "Nice", we'd think, "but when's Terre coming back?"
Well, Terre is back; and maybe it's just that I really, really missed those shimmering three-part harmonies for all those years, but this may well be the girls' best album since the late '70s. Time has frosted Maggie's hair, but apparently left no mark on the sisters' voices. Their crystalline vocals soar above their trademark ringing guitar work (gone the electric keyboards of the '80s albums), and it's like the past three decades never happened. And there is scarcely a song here (mostly penned by Suzzy and Terre) that isn't a gem.
But while Moonswept is a very good album, it's not a perfect album. For me, the cover of the Ames Brothers' "The Naughty Lady of Shady Lane" (one of the first songs the sisters ever sang together, and a long-time staple of their live shows) is a throw-away. If they were going to pull one out of the vaults, I'd have preferred "The Clothesline Saga". And while Suzzy's daughter, Lucy has a lovely voice, and her song ("Long Before") is a pretty one, this isn't her album and I could have done without this number. Maggie only contributed to the writing of two of the songs here, leaving the album a bit heavy on novelty songs, from the utterly delightful "Huh" (three minutes of nervous stammering set to music), to "Naughty Lady", to NYC songwriter Paranoid Larry's "No Shoes" and "Jesus Shaves" (both of which start out fun, only to wear out their welcome just a bit by the end). Moonswept would have benefited from a "One Season" or "This Feminine Position".
But I quibble. Moonswept is an eagerly awaited return to form for long-time Roches fans. In a better world, one could hope that this album might finally earn Maggie and Terre and Suzzy some of the mass recognition they have so richly deserved for so very, very long.