Modigliani [DVD] [2005] [Region 1] [US Import] [NTSC]

 

 

Create your own review

A very disappointing film that fails on several counts, from its dreadfully embarrassing opening scene and the hopelessly mis-cast Andy Garcia as Modigliani, to its load of old cobblers ending.
To begin with, he didn't die like that and the last words on Picassos lips were Modigliani?? Yeah right, I think not. Who ever wrote this tripe did not get a degree in Fine Art.
Whilst I have the greatest respect for Garcia as an actor, this was NOT the right part for him, it's a bit like casting Sylvester Stallone as Shakespeare's Hamlet, 'To be or what?' spoken with a heavy New York City accent. (see Robin Williams hilarious impression).
For a start Modi was young, he was only 34 when he died, he was by all accounts very handsome and he was very slim, in fact he was suffering from malnutrition when he died of T.B. Garcia did not look young and handsome or for that matter malnourished, quite the opposite , he's far too old to play a part like that. (Mind you, Garcia did co produce and co direct this film, maybe that's how he got the part).
In fairness though, we are warned that it is loosely based on Modigliani, this is somewhat of an overstatement to the point of being pure fiction. So why even bother to call the film Modigliani?
Also Picasso never ever regarded Modi as a rival, they painted in totally different styles, as those two utterly appalling paintings we are shown at the end, that Picasso and Modigliani would have turned in there graves at the sight of, proves my point. The films lumpen, leaden script apart from being inaccurate is very badly written and directed and I thought the story line was extremely immature, there was never a painting competition between Modi and Picasso, it just didn't happen. The film shows nothing of Modi's African Art influences, nothing of his painting technique, (inspired most definitely by Cezanne not Renoir, who he actually had no time for and told him so, yet another mistake this film makes), which if your going to make a film about a famous artist, you'd think detail is important, at least get some of your facts right.
There was only a brief portrayal of the extreme poverty he worked in; he was so impoverished, he used to paint on both sides of the canvas and stole railway sleepers from the new metro line for his carvings and fuel for his fire and his Caryatids were created from stone blocks removed from the roadside and construction sites late at night, the film shows none of this.
The films biggest flaw however is the lack of empathy you have with the main character Modigliani, you have little or no feeling for him, Garcia is very unconvincing. You do slightly feel for Jeanne Hebuterne, his last girlfriend, who was pregnant and had her other child taken away, this part was well acted by Elsa Zyberstein.
A very surprisingly good turn from Omid Djalili as Picasso. I thought he was very good and the filming and Camerawork direction by Emmanuel Kadosh is excellent. These are the films only plus points.
Modigliani's short life story of misunderstood genius is the stuff of legend, with all his doomed tempestuous love affairs and his excessive use of young prostitutes, he'd also had relationships with all his models for his famous nude paintings,not to mention the opium dens, hashish and absynthe abuse, he almost seemed like a Lord Byron of the art world, you'd have no need to make it up, just sticking to the facts would be enough. With all these ingredients, how could they possibly fail to make a great movie, instead this film was just an expensive wasted opportunity.

This film was made in 2004 and tells the story of the Italian/Jewish artist Amedeo Modigliani, his doomed love affair with Jeanne (Elsa Zylberstein) a young Catholic girl and his bitter rivalry with Picasso. In many ways it is like a 1950's Hollywood biopic- only not as good or as stylish. The direction is ponderous, the script is laughable in places and while there are many good actors involved - Peter Capaldi, Miriam Margolyes, Jim Carter etc - they are often under-employed, just standing around in the background.

Garcia is just about OK as "Modi"?!? but I couldn't really believe in him as a tortured genius, especially as Modigliani died at 35 and Garcia was 49 when he made the movie. The whole Salon D'Artists competition makes the film into an 'Art X Factor', although we are warned upfront that the film is mostly invention (but not that it is corny, cartoon-like melodrama). There was also no mention of why he painted his elongated figures - because he was influenced by African art.

The film does look good, with the streets of early-20th century Paris beautifully evoked in modern-day Romania. I also really like Omid Djalili as Picasso and the fact that he doesn't bother to change his Iranian accent for a cod Spanish one.

I think Modigliani's story is one that needs to be told but this film does not do justice to a great artist.

This film is nothing less than a masterpiece in my opinion! It really fascinated me, not having any knowledge about Modigliano in advance. The acting is brilliant and the story masterly told. It is so gripping seeing how hard life was for this artist. But also interesting to witness the feud he and Picasso were having. Tragedy, love and rivalry are all themes in this film. Living in total poverty and having suffered great loss, one can wonder how anyone can survive and also stay sane. And perhaps it wasn't possible.

The film is about Amedeo Clemente Modigliani's (July 12, 1884 - January 24, 1920) life as an artist in France in the beginning of the 20th century. He was an Italian artist of Jewish heritage and was practising both painting and sculpture. The film tells about his relationship with Jeanne Hébuterne who loves him so much that she can't live without him and because of that has to make inhuman sacrifices. And her father disapproves the affair so much that he commits unspeakable acts and makes their life even harder. It shows the rivalry between Modigliani and Picasso. And how he never in life gets the recognition he deserves, his disappointments and hopes to succeed. How he never gives up. And the tragic death of this great artist.

Share your thoughts with other customers: Create your own review

› See all 15 customer reviews on Amazon.co.uk

 

4.0 out of 5 stars Fantasy but very enjoyable.
As other reviewers have shown, this is not a serious depiction of the artist's life. As in so many biopics with artistic heroes the actual act of painting appears to be a very... Read more

Published 2 months ago by Keith Andreetti

5.0 out of 5 stars modligliani
this is a brilliant film music is fantastic and would recommend this to any one that enjoys a good film

Published 5 months ago by trish

5.0 out of 5 stars A MOVIE THATS HARD TO FIND
I first watched this movie in Estonia and wanted very much to see again but could not find in any video shop fantastic trajic movie,played well by Andy Garcia

Published 8 months ago by DAVE

4.0 out of 5 stars Magic
Excellent film and Andy Garcia was brilliant in the title role. Would recommend to anyone who likes music and art.

Published 8 months ago by hobbitses

3.0 out of 5 stars Modigliani - pure fiction
The problem with a film about a real person is that you don't know how much to believe - even with the disclaimer at the beginning I thought that there would be no point in making... Read more

Published 8 months ago by P. Howard

1.0 out of 5 stars films
Was sent the American area DVD, wont play on a UK machine, was to busy to sort out returning item.

Published 8 months ago by Davey

4.0 out of 5 stars andy garcia modigliani
enjoyed film.not what i expected.story was acted well by all participants. gave an insight into the painters of his era and his slow decline.

Published 9 months ago by phantom

5.0 out of 5 stars Superb film about Modigliani the Master
What a superb portrayal Andy Garcia was as Modigliani. Catching the duality of the artist where he was the showman and also the serious side where his art was his all. Read more

Published 15 months ago by eustacia vye

1.0 out of 5 stars Rubbish film with Dutch subtitles
I'm sure nobody will read this review because nobody would wish to buy the DVD

Enjoy

Published 21 months ago by G. Strettle

5.0 out of 5 stars Masterpiece!
This film is nothing less than a masterpiece in my opinion! It really fascinated me, not having any knowledge about Modigliano in advance. Read more

Published 23 months ago by Ingrid

Search Customer Reviews
Only search this product's reviews

› See all 15 customer reviews on Amazon.co.uk

Search Listmania!