Mistaken
and over one million other books are available for Amazon Kindle .
Learn more
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||
 Trade In this Item for up to £1.05
Get an extra £5 when you trade in books worth £10 or more until June 30, 2012. Trade in Mistaken for an Amazon.co.uk gift card of up to £1.05, which you can then spend on millions of items across the site. Trade-in values may vary (terms apply). Find more products eligible for trade-in.
|
Frequently Bought Together
Product details
|
More About the Author
Product Description
Review
Of all his books, Mistaken is perhaps the most universal - funny, mysterious and ultimately moving
(The Times )Nothing less than a plangent, incisive poetic wonder of a book
(Patrick McCabe, Irish Times )The novel is so precisely written, in every detail, each syllable weighed, or so it feels that reading slowly, you find yourself watermarked by a tale you don't wish to put down, and can't bear to end . . . Two thing make this tale a stand-out read: First, Jordan's restraint . . . The other coup is the novel's structure - it is essentially an intimate revelation . . . unputdownable
(Scotsman )Written with great skill, confidence and vim . . . utterly convincing: full of subtlety, delicate, piercing prose, charming, lively dialogue and descriptive passages that are poetic, witty and acute. At times it has the pace of a thriller, yet for all its highly specific subject matter it still manages to achieve a feeling of spaciousness in which it is possible for the writer to ponder, with a bit of leisure, the definition of human nature. A fine achievement, a powerful, involving and beautifully written book about identity and loss
(Financial Times )Jordan is a fine writer
(Time Out )A powerfully atmospheric book which turns Dublin into a murky maze of madness and melancholy
(Daily Mail )Neil Jordan has a good eye for visual detail
(TLS )*** a talented writer . . . Jordan's prose is persuasive and crystalline
(Metro )Product Description
'I had been mistaken for him so many times that when he died it was as if part of myself had died too.'
Kevin Thunder grew up with a double - a boy so uncannily like him that they were mistaken for each other at every turn. As children in 1960s
Inside This Book
(Learn More)
Tags Customers Associate with This Product(What's this?)Click on a tag to find related items, discussions, and people.
|
What Other Items Do Customers Buy After Viewing This Item?
Customer Reviews
Most Helpful Customer Reviews
6 of 6 people found the following review helpful
Format:Hardcover|Amazon Vine™ Review
(What's this?)
Neil Jordan is of course better known as a filmmaker, but I sometimes wonder whether he shouldn't receive more credit as a writer. Similar themes appear in both his films and books - coming to an accommodation with the past and with oneself, flawed characters carrying deep secrets, with a hint of supernatural or mysticism perhaps in there - but the material definitely seems to be given a more serious and credible examination in his novels, and - most importantly - it seems to touch on more personal subject matter.
Mistaken is a fine example of Jordan's writing, one that draws on the past, on childhood experiences, on growing up in Dublin in the 1960s, but it's one that, crucially, takes a distanced perspective, as if in awareness of the act of writing inevitably means creating a fiction of one's life. This is very much evident in the book's central conceit, where a young boy named Kevin Thunder, from a modest north Dublin working-class background feels that the has been living in the shadow of another person, a boy who looks exactly like him, Gerry Spain, but who has a more privileged southside upbringing. Being mistaken for someone else initially proves to be an annoyance to Kevin, but it also has its advantages, particularly when it comes to picking up the discarded girlfriends of his double. Inevitably however, the question of understanding one's true identity comes into question, both for Kevin and Gerry, as each of them come to wonder whether there isn't a third person that they have created between them.
That's very much a writer's conceit that has a number of well-known literary precedents from Mark Twain and Edgar Allan Poe to Dostoevsky - several of which are acknowledged in Mistaken - but inevitably, it's given more of a postmodernist spin here (which isn't exactly new either) on the question of identity and the role of the author. As such, home-grown literary giants such as Joyce and Stoker cast a long shadow over the two boys - quite literally in the case Kevin Thunder who grows up in the house next door to where Bram Stoker lived, and is haunted throughout by the shadow of his vampire creation - the division of those influences reflecting the split in the personality of two boys, made one perhaps in the author himself.
Such self-reflexive musings are interesting, but they do not become the overriding purpose of Mistaken, and Jordan finds a way to bring his own unique character to the writing with some beautiful childhood reminiscences of life in Dublin in the sixties (most of the chapter titles refer to Dublin locations). The Neil Jordan touches are there also in the obsessive dwelling on the past, memory, two halves seeking a whole and the skilful way he teases those elements out through an almost supernatural twist. Opening with a funeral, Mistake is also about Death in wider sense - the death of parents and a generation which nonetheless leave ghosts of a past that still haunt and direct the course of our lives.
Despite the clear personal input, the literary nature of the book does perhaps prevent the characters from fully coming to life, but that shouldn't be seen as a criticism, since the whole purpose of Mistaken is to examine "the inadequacies of fiction" in its creation of characters and in the dangerous pursuit of dreaming of another life. Nonetheless, the novel is beautifully written, wonderfully rich in imagery and observations, but also consistent and persuasive in its worldview and, ultimately, despite itself, even quite touching.
Mistaken is a fine example of Jordan's writing, one that draws on the past, on childhood experiences, on growing up in Dublin in the 1960s, but it's one that, crucially, takes a distanced perspective, as if in awareness of the act of writing inevitably means creating a fiction of one's life. This is very much evident in the book's central conceit, where a young boy named Kevin Thunder, from a modest north Dublin working-class background feels that the has been living in the shadow of another person, a boy who looks exactly like him, Gerry Spain, but who has a more privileged southside upbringing. Being mistaken for someone else initially proves to be an annoyance to Kevin, but it also has its advantages, particularly when it comes to picking up the discarded girlfriends of his double. Inevitably however, the question of understanding one's true identity comes into question, both for Kevin and Gerry, as each of them come to wonder whether there isn't a third person that they have created between them.
That's very much a writer's conceit that has a number of well-known literary precedents from Mark Twain and Edgar Allan Poe to Dostoevsky - several of which are acknowledged in Mistaken - but inevitably, it's given more of a postmodernist spin here (which isn't exactly new either) on the question of identity and the role of the author. As such, home-grown literary giants such as Joyce and Stoker cast a long shadow over the two boys - quite literally in the case Kevin Thunder who grows up in the house next door to where Bram Stoker lived, and is haunted throughout by the shadow of his vampire creation - the division of those influences reflecting the split in the personality of two boys, made one perhaps in the author himself.
Such self-reflexive musings are interesting, but they do not become the overriding purpose of Mistaken, and Jordan finds a way to bring his own unique character to the writing with some beautiful childhood reminiscences of life in Dublin in the sixties (most of the chapter titles refer to Dublin locations). The Neil Jordan touches are there also in the obsessive dwelling on the past, memory, two halves seeking a whole and the skilful way he teases those elements out through an almost supernatural twist. Opening with a funeral, Mistake is also about Death in wider sense - the death of parents and a generation which nonetheless leave ghosts of a past that still haunt and direct the course of our lives.
Despite the clear personal input, the literary nature of the book does perhaps prevent the characters from fully coming to life, but that shouldn't be seen as a criticism, since the whole purpose of Mistaken is to examine "the inadequacies of fiction" in its creation of characters and in the dangerous pursuit of dreaming of another life. Nonetheless, the novel is beautifully written, wonderfully rich in imagery and observations, but also consistent and persuasive in its worldview and, ultimately, despite itself, even quite touching.
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful
Format:Hardcover|Amazon Vine™ Review
(What's this?)
After finding the first hundred pages hard going in places I enjoyed this book very much. It is a poetic, meditative account of growing up and ageing, the choices we make and those that are made for us and how things might have turned out if either had been different. The book's central idea of the narrator and his double often being mistaken for each other is well developed and ingeniously used to illustrate what Jordan is trying to say about how lives develop, and the later part of the book has a very gripping story.
Neil Jordan has the ability to pick out those few details which capture a scene or an atmosphere perfectly. For example, the narrator as a boy in the early 60s catches a bus thus: "...I ran, jumped on to the tailboard, grabbed the rail and climbed the stairs to the upper deck. The cigarette smoke was thick, the windows dripping with condensation...", which really struck a chord with me. I am sure other readers will find flashes of their own past brought vividly to life in the same way, and it is one of the great strengths of the book.
I found the events and characters very well-drawn and believable, and Jordan also tells a very good involving story which I found quite heartbreaking in places. My only criticism of this book is that in the first hundred or so pages the fractured, occasionally confusing timescale and the extremely leisurely pace did begin to pall, and I thought the poetic language and descriptions occasionally spilled over into self-indulgence. However, the latter two-thirds of the book are really impressive and enjoyable, and have left me with powerful images and plenty to think about. It's a very rewarding book and even if you find the opening a struggle it is well worth persevering with.
Neil Jordan has the ability to pick out those few details which capture a scene or an atmosphere perfectly. For example, the narrator as a boy in the early 60s catches a bus thus: "...I ran, jumped on to the tailboard, grabbed the rail and climbed the stairs to the upper deck. The cigarette smoke was thick, the windows dripping with condensation...", which really struck a chord with me. I am sure other readers will find flashes of their own past brought vividly to life in the same way, and it is one of the great strengths of the book.
I found the events and characters very well-drawn and believable, and Jordan also tells a very good involving story which I found quite heartbreaking in places. My only criticism of this book is that in the first hundred or so pages the fractured, occasionally confusing timescale and the extremely leisurely pace did begin to pall, and I thought the poetic language and descriptions occasionally spilled over into self-indulgence. However, the latter two-thirds of the book are really impressive and enjoyable, and have left me with powerful images and plenty to think about. It's a very rewarding book and even if you find the opening a struggle it is well worth persevering with.
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful
Format:Hardcover|Amazon Vine™ Review
(What's this?)
When I saw the blurb for this I thought that it sounded intriguing, so thus ordered it to give it a go. I think it must be about five or six years since Neil Jordan last had a book out so it is nice to see something new from him.
Meet Kevin Thunder, he is attending a funeral of someone he once knew well. At the funeral he meets the deceased's daughter, Emily, and it is through this that the memories and confessions come flooding back. Growing up next door to the former house of Bram Stoker, Kevin leads a rather normal life, but then he starts to find that he gets mistaken for someone else, and thus he eventually meets Gerald Spain. Both live opposite sides of Dublin, but there is an uncanny resemblance between them. From childhood onwards they find that they can walk in and out of each other's lives and be the other. Keeping this a secret, very few people know the truth, with disastrous results.
With their secrets and identical resemblance this becomes a tale that grows on you, and makes you wonder what identity really means. Quite slowly paced this is something that I think you will either love or loathe.
Meet Kevin Thunder, he is attending a funeral of someone he once knew well. At the funeral he meets the deceased's daughter, Emily, and it is through this that the memories and confessions come flooding back. Growing up next door to the former house of Bram Stoker, Kevin leads a rather normal life, but then he starts to find that he gets mistaken for someone else, and thus he eventually meets Gerald Spain. Both live opposite sides of Dublin, but there is an uncanny resemblance between them. From childhood onwards they find that they can walk in and out of each other's lives and be the other. Keeping this a secret, very few people know the truth, with disastrous results.
With their secrets and identical resemblance this becomes a tale that grows on you, and makes you wonder what identity really means. Quite slowly paced this is something that I think you will either love or loathe.
Would you like to see more reviews about this item?
Were these reviews helpful?
Let us know
Most Recent Customer Reviews
A slow start but a satisfying onclusion
As with many of Neil Jordan's films, 'Mistaken' features two central characters brought together across social divisions who form an intimate connection. Read more
Published 9 months ago by M. D. Smart
Modern gothic
Mistaken is a slow-starter. I found myself in the unusual position of loving the writing, the style, the imagery and the voice but not particularly enjoying the story. Read more
Published 12 months ago by S. Holt
Magisterially slow but worth the wait
This is a difficult novel to review without revealing spoilers - but let's just say it's about a Dublin boy who seems to have a double for whom he is constantly mistaken. Read more
Published 12 months ago by C. O'Brien
A complex but riviting read. Recommended.
I shared this book with my father, as it is not the normal sort of read for me. I have to admit that I struggled to get into this book, but it was worth sticking to it. Read more
Published 13 months ago by Joanne K. Pilsworth
A fascinating idea
My wife's review:
An intriguing idea - somebody who looks so much like you that you are mistaken for them. Read more
An intriguing idea - somebody who looks so much like you that you are mistaken for them. Read more
Published 13 months ago by John Ferngrove
Worth the effort
It's really hard to say that you 'like' this kind of book, but the overall feeling you are left with is that it made a decent impression. Read more
Published 13 months ago by C. CAMPBELL
Mistaken by Neil Jordan
Mistaken by Neil Jordan
A review Emer O'Regan
A great read; this is the most visually powerful book I have read in a long time. Read more
A review Emer O'Regan
A great read; this is the most visually powerful book I have read in a long time. Read more
Published 13 months ago by Ms. Emer M. O'regan
A slow burner, but worth it.
Mistaken started slowly and, for the first hundred pages or so, I wondered if I was going to like it. I'm glad I persevered because I did. Read more
Published 13 months ago by Gary Nicklin
Mistaken - Don't mistake this for a thriller/mystery!
This is NOT a fast moving thriller, or even a mystery story really. It is a slow, thoughtful portrait of life in Dublin in the nineteen sixties. Read more
Published 14 months ago by GM Harlow
Whose Life is it Anyway?
Neil Jordan is a man of many talents - director of fantastic films such as The Crying Game and Mona Lisa as well as a successful novelist. Read more
Published 14 months ago by Lovely Treez
Customer Discussions
|
This product's forum
Active discussions in related forums
Search Customer Discussions
|
Related forums
|
Listmania!
|
|
Look for similar items by category
Look for similar items by subject
Feedback
- Would you like to update product info or give feedback on images?
- I am the Author, and I want to comment on my book.
- I am the Publisher, and I want to comment on this book.
|
