|
8 of 9 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Book better than the film!, 25 Mar 2004
This book is a masterful tale, rich in the flavor of the 'old west' and full of brilliant characterisations.If you've seen the film, and liked it to any degree, READ THE BOOK. If you haven't seen the film, READ THE BOOK (and they see it if you'd still like to, it's not bad). The book, however, is much better than the film. I don't know why Ron Howard, such a wonderful director, didn't want to direct a closer version. (Tommy Lee Jones and Cate Blanchett deliver great performances tho) After seeing the movie you'll think you know how it ends, but it's sufficiently different to keep you reading. The relationship between Samuel and Maggie is explored in all its dimension, and you really empathise with them. None of the characters are cliched; Eidson instills them each with a unique personality. Running throughout the book are other areas of thought and conflict, ie the meaning of faith, of God, and how to hold on to one's belief. If you like adventure, Westerns, and characters that linger with you after reading it (I still think of Samuel from time to time) then I recommend this book.
|