Most Helpful Customer Reviews
25 of 25 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Smilla is my all-time favourite literary character, 25 Feb 1999
By A Customer
The original, witty, intelligent, unconventional character of Smilla Jasperson is well drawn and quite unlike any other character I have ever met in life or fiction... and yet, given her background, she just could be real. Apart from the wonderful Smilla, I was fascinated with the descriptions of Greenland, the people who survive in its hostile climate and its relationship with (a largely unsympathetic) Denmark. There is also a very exciting and intricate plot which keeps you guessing until the end. Clues are introduced to the reader all the way through and because of this, it is not a book to pick up and put down over a long period of time. In fact I wish I could have had the time to read it in just one or two sessions. I also wish I had made notes on the various characters as they were introduced because you tend to forget where they came in: Partly due to the complex nature of the plot-weaving and partly the unfamiliar Scandinavian names.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
27 of 28 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A shiver of pleasure, 3 April 2005
Peter Høeg's Smilla is a fairly unique sort of person. Her experiences have made her wise in the ways of snow and ice and cynical and distrustful of people. An Inuit upbringing in the cold climate of Greenland had ill-prepared her for the chilly atmosphere of Danish society when her father took her there after her mother died. At 37 she is single, solitary and unemployed - even though she's one of the world's leading experts on ice and snow. She has just one friend that she loves: a small boy, Isaiah, who is, like her, a Greenlander out of place in Denmark. When Isaiah falls to his death from a rooftop, Smilla knows it cannot have been a simple accident. She can read his footprints in the snow and she knew the child well. The authorities cannot be allowed to write it off as an accidental death so she sets out to discover what really happened. The feeling of snow and ice: the cold, the motion and gradual stiffening of the sea, the changing quality of the light - are conveyed so that, with a little imagination, it's possible to feel it. I put on an extra jumper and turned the heating up a bit. The description of Smilla's journey from the desolation of the lonely city to the desolation of the ice fields west of Greenland generate strong visual and emotional impressions. The plot is quite complicated to follow and there are a few coincidences that might require the brief suspension of disbelief. It can also be rather a bumpy ride for an English speaking reader because of the many Danish and Greenlandic words and names that can slow you down as you try to puzzle out how they should be pronounced. Even so, it's a splendid book, full of tragic and colourful characters, most of them deeply or slightly flawed (even the goodies) but all of them interesting and plausible. I highly recommend this book.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
9 of 9 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
A really great read!, 21 Jan 2010
I loved this book for many reasons. The reluctant heroine Miss Smilla is sometimes charming and funny, sometimes touchingly honest, always very human and easy to identify with. The narration is precise and atmospheric, and the mixture of Greenland culture and Danish society is fascinating. The world through the eyes of the sometimes over-dramatic Smilla is a dark and hostile place, full of threats and tentative bonds with people which break too easily. Her relationship with the little boy is descibed with great tenderness and honesty, whic perfectly validates her heartbreak when he dies and her extreme actions following his death. Also, the sweet love story between Smilla and the mechanic adds softness and warmth in the middle of all the hostile chill.
My reservations relate to the plot mostly - It starts out very simply, the boy falls to his death from a roof, and when the police decide it is an accidental death, Smilla disagrees and decides to dig further. From then on the plot grows into a bit of a beast, all conspiracy theories and mad scientists. I feel like the book lost some of its beauty along with it's simplicity. Also, the 'baddies' aren't very strong characters, so in the middle of all the action I found it quite hard to tell them apart.
But mainly it is a very very good book, I was totally absorbed and would recommend it to everyone.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|