I'm not really an expert on the mythology of Merlin and the like, as I've never really held an avid interest, so I can give an unbiased review of the film without having to refer to the inaccuracies of the film compared to the legend. But no telling of a fictional legend is really right or wrong, and this is where some reviewers miss the point of the film. But hey, people have different opinions.
I missed the two part series when it was shown on Channel 4, but was attracted by the TV advertisements, and it was refreshing to see a reasonably big budget production made primarily for TV. When it was released on video, it was a welcome purchase as I could see what I had missed. And I loved it.
It was nice to see such an impressive cast in MERLIN. Sam Neill was good as the lead character. Miranda Richardson, playing yet another 'bad girl' role positively oozed evil as Queen Mab. Helena Bonham Carter played her part as the lispy Morgan well, and Martin Short... well, you couldn't fault his performance which was equaly parts sincere, hilarious and over the top. Rutger Hauer was pretty good, although I felt that his part was taken to the extreme in places, with his evil character taken often to an unbelievable extreme (take his treatment of the castle architects for example). But that was the fault of the writers, not his. But saying that, that is about the only place in the film where the writers goofed; the rest was top notch.
The special effects were brilliant, from start to finish. In some places you could tell that computer animation was used (take the dragon scene for instance), but they look so good that you can't fault them. Queen Mab's erratic movement from one area to another, Martin Short's character metamorphosis, the dragon, the fairies and the final showdown are all breathtaking when considering that MERLIN was a TV production.
And the musical score by Trevor Jones... for me this is the high point of MERLIN, as it is quite simply one of the best scores committed to moving image. Movie enthusiasts will recognise his name from such films as EXCALIBUR, and, most notably, LAST OF THE MOHICANS (containing the best musical score in the world!), and his music expertly captures the majesty, the fantasy and the scope of the film. It cannot be faulted.
Definetly a film for all ages, this is a truly pleasurable, visual treat from start to finish. Definetly one to watch.