The conventions of Gothic romance are endlessly adaptable. While elastic enough to please fans of low-rent bodice rippers and highbrow fiction alike, the Gothic pattern of moves, symbols and character types can be woven by expert hands into something new and surprisingly contemporary. "Mere Mortals," by Erastes, is such a one.
The novel opens with a journey, first by coach, then boat, across the Norfolk Broads, a network of marshy rivers and lakes, ending at a large and mysterious mansion on a remote island. Young Crispin Thorne, a penniless orphan, having been removed from boarding school, arrives at Bittern's Reach, the seat of wealthy, well-bred Philip Smallwood, his newly named guardian. He is accompanied part of the way by another local worthy, Dr. Baynes. The latter, surprised to hear Thorne's story, indicates, without much explanation until later in the book, that neither he nor most members of the community are on close terms with Mr. Smallwood.
Thorne is greeted not by the master but by servants and by news that two other orphans, Myles Graham and Jude Middleton, have also been installed as Smallwood's wards. A program of gentlemanly education is begun forthwith. Each is given a valet, tailored clothes, handmade boots and other accouterments for every occasion, expensive watches, lessons in riding, fencing, music and dance, and tutoring on a variety of more academic subjects.
As individuals, the boys are almost entirely unalike. Where Thorne is shy, Jude is sly and sexually aggressive and Myles an athletic, more manly man type. Differences aside, what they have in common is at least a passing acquaintance with male-male desire or, to use their term, "inversion." Taken together, the trio stands in for the maiden in distress of Gothic convention. What's unconventional is that they not only discuss their previous experiences but begin to experiment among themselves.
Smallwood, all steely charm, returns, tutoring his wards further in the niceties of polite society. At odd moments, the boys explore the huge house, discovering secret doors, hidden passageways, forbidden rooms and evidence that all is not as it seems, either in their good fortune or in the mansion in which they have come to dwell. Smallwood decides to give a party, a sort of debut, to introduce his new wards to the neighboring gentry. There is a storm, a quarrel between the host and Dr. Byrne, the revelation of long buried secrets as well as new ones and ... enough! No spoilers here.
Erastes is a master of gay historical fiction. This is one of her best tales. Enjoy the ride for yourself.