I bought this for my 3yr old's birthday, and it has been a huge hit. It's good quality, there is a fairly wide variety of outfits and shoes, and tbh I think it has value in helping her to understand what type of clothes go together - she's now making those decisions for herself as well as Maggie.
The lid (or lack of it) is a minor niggle, as the rest of the box is wooden and it is obviously meant for storage. But easily solved by slipping into a fabric bag if we take it anywhere. And we honestly hadn't noticed the lack of a swimming costume of pyjamas!