I had to stop listening to this album on the first few attempts. The question `what the f**k?' was constantly ringing through my head, along with shifting enjoyment and cringing. And really, numerous listens later, I still don't really know. "Meanderthal" is some kind of pop-sludge-mainstream rock-doom-prog metal thing. And I'm really unsure what to think of it all.
Torche's EP "In Return" was all I had previously sampled, and it was good, fuzzy stoner metal with some doom and shoegaze influences. "Meanderthal" is a whole new sound. The first two tracks are immediate examples of this, with the opener "Triumph of Venus" drifting into cheesy prog-metal, masturbatory guitar noodling, whizzing up and down an ascending scale pattern. It's terribly cliched and just completely bores me. Then "Grenades" comes in with an insipid guitar hook, followed by some rank vocal harmonies that sound ripped from a throwaway North American emo-rock band. But then, once I picked up the confidence to go beyond track two, I found some real enjoyment.
There are times when the odd pop-stoner sound works. This is most notable with "Across The Shields", which builds to an absolute blast of a finale - a booming happy-sounding riff thunders in, the vocal harmonies actually work, and it's all fitting into place. It's fun stoner metal. I bob my head along with a smile. This song is what every song on "Meanderthal" should be doing, yet only a small few accomplish.
I understand that the stoner/doom genre is quite inaccessible for many. There is room for a band from the genre to bring in a more immediate and catchy sound, and at times "Meanderthal" achieves this. But there is too much variation. Often I can both enjoy and deeply loathe moments within the same song. So, fans of stoner/doom expecting more of "In Return" should approach with caution. Those who want a more catchy heaviness might want to give it a try.