I've been reading Dickens' novels in the same order as he wrote them for a couple of months now, and before I began 'Martin Chuzzlewit' I did a quick search on the web and stumbled on dozens of webpages referring to this novel either as 'one of the lesser works' or - conversely - as 'sadly neglected'. Well, which is it? I could not help but wonder and eagerly began reading, and now, having finished it I'm rather of the 'sadly neglected'-school I must say.
True, 'Martin Chuzzlewit' is perhaps not in the same category as 'The Pickwick Papers', 'Barnaby Rudge' or 'Oliver Twist' (I'm limiting myself to novels I've actually read) but it is in its own right a very very enjoyable novel! Dickens set out (as he states in his preface) to picture selfishness, 'the commonest of all vices', and the damage it can wreak on human relations and society at large, and he does so admirably to my mind. The entire Chuzzlewit-family, old Martin Chuzzlewit foremost, are a greedy, grasping lot, and (young) Martin Chuzzlewit seems set on the same path at the beginning of the book. It'll take a trip to the US and a near fatal illness to gain self-knowledge and maturity, and bring about a reunion with old Martin.
As often with Dickens, there are perhaps some minor flaws in the plot but, as always with Dickens, there are some truly unforgettable characters. Jonas Chuzzlewit is surely one of the most odious fictional characters I've come across, but it is perhaps the arch-hypocrite Mr Pecksniff that I'll remember the most. The way Dickens succeeds in portraying him, and flawlessly depicts him is stunning. There are some heart-rending scenes (Merry Pecksniff at the mercy of Jonas Chuzzlewit) but there is lots and lots of humour too involving Mark Tapley (Martin's companion in the US), Thomas Pinch, young Bailey, and scores of others...
So, to sum up: this is indeed perhaps not Dickens' best, but even a 'minor' Dickens is still a remarkably good book, well worth reading!