Judging by the lack of other customer reviews, it would seem that 'Mansfield Park' has the unfortunate reputation of being Austen's most unpopular novel. The fact that the few film and television adaptations of it have all turned out to be complete disasters also doesn't help much (although many people claim that the BBC- miniseries of 1983 is rather good; it at least sticks closely to the original plot). Patricia Rozema's 2000 film turned out to be a rather daring and risqué version, loosely based on the book, while the ITV- production of 2007 was utter drivel from beginning to end. Perhaps its just one of those novels from which you can attain its true message through reading only...?
Fanny Price, the heroine of the novel, is probably the main cause of its unpopularity, because she doesn't act like a heroine at all. As Tony Tanner mentions in the introduction, she is a girl `who accomplishes by doing nothing.' Not that she doesn't do anything, but she certainly doesn't do anything worthwhile to earn her the honour and status of `heroine': she is almost passive, and suffers mentally, but solves it by crying it out most of the time. Compared with Elizabeth Bennet from 'Pride and Prejudice' and Emma Woodhouse, Fanny is rather dull and mousy in regards to character (though she is described as `beautiful' several times). Even so, physical attractiveness is not enough to make a character a hero or heroine.
But like any other protagonist, Fanny must overcome a few obstacles in order to achieve greatness.
Fanny is adopted into the house of her rich family, Sir Thomas and Lady Bertram, at Mansfield Park, due to the current poverty of her family. Once there, she clearly begins to feel her social inferiority with regards to the treatment enhanced by her cousins: spoiled Tom, Maria and Julia. Their brother Edmund is the only one of them who treats Fanny with kindness and who goes out of his way for her. Fanny values her friendship with Edmund, and as she matures, her feelings for him do likewise.
The trouble begins a few years later, with the arrival of handsome Henry Crawford and his sister Mary; the latter being a most beautiful and accomplished woman. Once there, they openly flirt their way into the lives of the Park: Maria (already engaged) and Julia fall head over heels for Henry Crawford; and Edmund, upright and responsible fellow that he is, becomes attracted to Mary. Fanny is the only one who dislikes and mistrusts the Crawfords and their actions. As the drama heightens, Fanny's dislike of them and her fear of their influence become more and more clear, as this influence leads to disastrous consequences.
'Mansfield Park' is, at its core, a very dramatic work, much more than either 'Northanger Abbey', 'Sense and Sensibility' and 'Pride and Prejudice'. It is rightfully described as being the first of Austen's `mature' novels. The comedy scenes are much fewer, though there are quite a number of scenes to entertain her reader, and the references to other books, authors, and contemporary happenings occur frequently. These elements, however, make it a bit of a difficult read, and consequently an unpopular one.
In the end, I advise any first-time Janeites out there NOT to read this as their first one, for the risk of it putting you off forever from Austen is rather high, and that is the last thing I want to see happening. But after you've got two or three of her works under the belt (you MUST at least have read 'Pride and Prejudice'), then a serious yet entertaining novel awaits your reading appetite.