Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
A fantastic read, but not one for the neutrals, 10 Dec 2008
Manchester United: The Biography is a finely written book, but not without its flaws. Principal among these is its bias. White may be a journalist, but he is also a die-hard United fan, and he writes like one. While this brings a certain authenticity to the work, it also renders it nigh-on unreadable for anyone who isn't of a United persuasion. I'm a United fan myself, but even I found myself cringing at some of White's assertions. There is a particularly distasteful passage in which White compares the 1958 Munich air disaster to the tragedies at Hillsborough, Heysel and Valley Parade and concludes that Munich had "a much more intense symbolism". United are praised for recovering more quickly from the disaster than Italian side Torino did when their team was wiped out in a similar accident in 1949, but the whole business of comparing tragedies leaves a sour taste and would probably better have been avoided.
In White's defence, though, he's not afraid to criticise, and key figures such as Roy Keane, Bryan Robson, Cristiano Ronaldo, former chairman Martin Edwards and even Alex Ferguson himself are all castigated for their perceived failings.
There are also, as Pat Stenson notes, multiple factual errors. That they appear in the book is probably a testament to White's confidence in his own memory of the events he witnessed first-hand, but even a cursory glance at YouTube will reveal that Brian Kidd was not wearing a "blazer" when he leapt on the pitch to celebrate the crucial 2-1 win over Sheffield Wednesday in 1992-1993, while a cursory glance at Wikipedia will tell you that Jaap Stam was indeed bought from PSV Eindhoven rather than Ajax.
One of the most obvious errors occurs on the very last page, where White refers to United youngster Danny Welbeck as "Daniel Welback". When White was writing the book Welbeck was still very much an unknown, but he has since made his Premier League debut (scoring a superb goal against Stoke in the process), and the fact the mistake is in the very last paragraph means it colours your final assessment of the book's accuracy.
Likewise, White sometimes shows a fondness for anecdotal evidence that is impossible to verify. The story about a player submerging himself in a bath of freezing cold water for half an hour to escape one of Ferguson's trademark rants certainly raises a smile, but it's almost definitely untrue.
But in spite of all that, the book is a tremendous achievement, and White's wide-ranging account of United's history is informed by the enormous role the club has evidently played in his own life. He is at his best when writing about the Tommy Docherty era of the late 1970s, when United emerged from the old Second Division to become once again one of the most entertaining sides in the land, and it is clear that it was during this period that White was first blooded on the raucous Old Trafford terraces. Now a journalist, his account of the Ferguson era is accompanied by intriguing chunks of insider information, lending a freshness to a period in the club's history that has been extremely well-documented already thanks to the huge growth of media interest in the game over the last 15 years or so.
This book is an insightful, warm-hearted and at times beautifully written love letter to White's favourite club and fellow fanatics will find much to savour in it. Neutrals and United fans not blinded by their love of the club, on the other hand, may find it a little harder to swallow.
|
|
|
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Man U.-The Boigraphy- A View from the States, 1 Oct 2008
In order for a review to be meaningful, I believe one must have a basic understanding of the "reviewer". Hence I am a New York lawyer from a soccer and Man U loving family who is well versed in soccer-football history, having bought many books from Amazon UK (and even having read some). This is the first time that I am discussing a book in this kind of forum. I first became aware of Jim White via his book "Always in the Running." I enjoyed it so much that I went on to read "The Biography." This new book is fantastic. It is witty, analytical, entertainig and extremely informative. It is clear that Mr. White neither has an "axe to grind" nor does he simply follow "the party line." Therefore, in my opinion, he has effectively accomplished writing an outstanding objective history of this endlessly fascinating institution.
|
|
|
6 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Engrossing and entertaining, 15 Sep 2008
This is another excellent book about United by Jim White. Far from the usual dull collection of facts and figures, this is an incisive, insightful journey through the history of Manchester United. From the early days of Newton Heath, through the barren inter-war years, the magical Busby Babes to the trophy-laden Ferguson years, White gives a superb illustration of the character of United and the characters that made the club what it is today. He superbly illustrates the backdrop of a changing industrial city with passion and humour, perfectly placing the reader in the realities of the day.
The only criticism I would have is that there are numerous glaring factual errors - for example, the words 'Football Club' were removed from the badge in 1998, not the initials 'F.C'; Gordon McQueen did not equalise in the 1979 Cup Final, rather Sammy McIlroy after McQueen had pulled one back (despite what Lou Macari bizarrely states!); Bryan Robson did not score 'the winner' in the 1994 FA Cup Semi-final, but the third goal in a 4-1 victory; and Jaap Stam was signed from PSV, not Ajax.
These are small details, however. On the whole this is a hugely entertaining read. Highly recommended.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|
![Manchester United - End Of Season Review 2007/2008 [DVD]](http://ecx.images-amazon.com/images/I/51fv3K7jXcL._SL500_SS90_.jpg)
DVD ~ Manchester United Fc
![Manchester United: Ryan Giggs - True Red [DVD]](http://ecx.images-amazon.com/images/I/51aFceOpIsL._SL500_SS90_.jpg)
DVD ~ Ryan Giggs
by Bobby Charlton
![Manchester United - The Official History 1878-2008 [DVD]](http://ecx.images-amazon.com/images/I/41hTEcchOcL._SL500_SS90_.jpg)
DVD ~ Manchester United Fc
![Manchester United - The Official History 1878-2008 [DVD]](http://ecx.images-amazon.com/images/I/41hTEcchOcL._SL75_SS50_.jpg)
With an Amazon.co.uk Gift Certificate, you can get them what they want (even if you don't know what that is). 
Amazon Home