Averaging the highs and lows of this book, the overall "averageness" makes it hard to get exited enough either way.
An unlikely young hero, a quest, evil sorcerers and arrogant lordlings it begins as "Standard Fantasy Tale, Plot No.4b (Coming of age and Life Quest)" but eventually degenerates in to a dull soup of Faith against Rational Proof with some ape sex thrown in to spice things up along the way.
The good points - the alternative Colonial setting in a world where the gears of creation are a physical brass reality, visible in the sky and the landscape, all nicely described in such a way as to make the sheer immensity of it all quite real.
The bad points -
1. The way that the aforementioned mechanism is used as a less than subtle constant reminder of the Hand of God visible in all things.
2. The whole book is a "quest of faith" and, like listening to anyone banging on about a religious argument (in this case God vs Rational Humanism) you tend to glaze over after a while. It is a basic religious fable of someones search for God whilst fighting the Unbelievers along the way. Not exacly a Christian morality tale - the ape-sex would rather jar against this....
3. Corny plot devices pushing the character along the pre-ordained linear track of the story. You will often find yourself saying "Why would any rational person DO that in such a situation?"
4. The disjointed storyline with holes, sudden leaps and the disappearance and reappearance of characters and unexplained mystical powers. Hosts of characters set up and then cast aside with no further mention of their fate.
5 Finally - The ending. The ending of this book is terrible. I mean, really terrible. For anyone wanting to read this book I won't give away anything but, be warned, if you are over the age of 12 you'll be torn between laughing out loud and vomiting at the sheer Dan-Brown-Like cod-spirituality of the whole mess.