We can say this is the best cycle of Mahler's songs on CD. Of course there are marvellous performances available on the stores (Dieskau-Furtwängler, Baker-Barbirolli, Dieskau-Kubelik...), performances you will need if you want to discover some of the possibilities this songs offer, but if I'm asked for the most completely couple of the lieder I would say this is the one, the recordings in which everything is quite perfect, the singer, the orchestra, the conductor and the recording. Apart from being everything perfect, the recordings transmit the deep emotions the performances gave even to the artists we listen here; we have to remember Hampson's words about the end of Kindertotenlieder, after which both singer and conductor were crying of emotion, something I hope we can watch in a future DVD if these concerts are released.
Thomas Hampson is, in my opinion, the best mahlerian singer in our days, with a property personality, not trying to go into Fischer-Dieskau steps, something very important, because that use to be the `fault' of many singers, to try to `copy' the maestro. His understanding of every lieder is very deep and I really prefer man's voice for these songs than the very usual female one, for many reasons, one of them because of the songs' texts, which are really told by a man. Of course that feelings could be felt by every human being, man or woman, but I found the sense much more apropiate to be sung by a bariton... in my opinion, of course.
The orchestral playing is simply terrific and electrifying, perfect from quite all the points of view. Bernstein's baton understand Mahler's universe like no one and he represents the last years of a period in Mahler performing, the last maestros of the second half of XXth Century. This CD is, in my opinion one of his best in Mahler, and that's really too much. The dynamics, the tempi, the technical playing is perfect and the recording is so good we can listen everything. The piece called `In diesem Wetter in diesem Braus' is a clear example of how amazing this CD can be. I have never listen this like in this CD. The last piece is marvellous too, the contrasts are perfectely done always.
The sound is magnificent and the booklet great, with a beautiful photo of the concert.
I hope it will be released on DVD soon, because it's one of the best Mahler's recording I know... and I know hundreds... I hope we can finish the watching of that DVD on tears, like the players... this music sometimes hurts, it have to be so...
STRONGLY RECOMMENDED.