Having been a long time devotee of the madden franchise through Nintendo, Megadrive and PS2 I was eargerly awaiting the release of 09.
I decided to get Madden 09 on Wii as the reviews of Madden 09 on PS2 basically said there was little improvement on 08. I admit I was sceptical given some reviews I read on other sites.
First impressions were the graphics are an improvement on PS2, but you should change the visual settings as per the instruction booklet.
I did start to get frustrated with the controls at first, but am getting the hang of it, though still haven't mastered catching. I have tried several minicamps and the Learn Madden function, both of which teach you the basics quite well. The controls will probably mean that the game will never be as easy on All Madden as the PS2, but that isn't a bad thing.
The game moves quicker than the PS2 between plays, thankfully! There is also the option of picking plays by style, ie Inside Run, Outside Run, Short, Medium, Long Passes, Play Action etc. Its a nice change if you know you're in a throwing down and want to see your options. For Madden veterans, don't worry the option to select play by formation is still there. For beginners there is also an even more simplified option of play selection until you learn the ropes.
All the usual suspects are there, historic teams, Franchise mode, Superstar mode etc and I haven't seen too much different yet. I haven't tried the 5 on 5 yet, but it looks more like a "multiplayer with a few pints in you" mode than a serious game.
All in all I'm happy so far and have just started a franchise mode. If after a few days I get sick of the controls, I'll let you know.
For Madden devotees with a wii, its worth a punt, but bear with the controls for a while.
For non-nfl wii fans, this version of Madden is far easier to pick up and learn than any previous version I have played. If you're interested in a sports game that could get incredibly addictive, give this a look.