I know Lucy Talk has been out for a bit, so hard core Fiona Walker fans will have already read it and made their own judgments. For the rest of you - here's my take. Including Lucy Talk, I've read all but one of the Fiona Walker's that have been released. (There's a new one, Lots of Love, due out soon.) I have a bit of a love-hate thing going on with Walker's books. Even with French Relations and Well Groomed (both of which I've read more than once), you always feel as if you are witnessing a train wreck as you read on. With a less lovable heroine than Tash French, (such as Juno in Snap Happy) you find it hard to root for someone who just goes out of her way to screw up her life so. And Walker is a master at creating truly, truly unlikable auxiliary characters and "heroes" that are more than a bit flawed. But, like the proverbial train wreck that you just can't stop yourself from watching, you find yourself hooked on her books once you get into them. So, having said that - Lucy Talk is COMPLETELY different. I can well understand the 1 star and 5 star range of ratings. That's not to say that Walker isn't writing with that classic Walker "voice", it's just executed in a very different way and the result is more light-hearted than her other efforts. As stated in other reviews, this book is a collection of emails, electronic journal entries, letters, party invitations, menus (very,very funny), notes posted on the fridge, shopping lists - you name it. When you think about trying to tell a complete story using this device, you have to applaud Walker - because it seems impossible that a cohesive fiction plot could roll out this way, but it does. Daffy Lucy starts out one Halloween with a love rat boyfriend and a little over a year later, we've seen her become engaged, become un-engaged, lose friends, find friends, suffer career setbacks, celebrate career gains. The cast of characters is so clever - I especially liked Charles the snob (you can't convince me the driving incident was an accident!) and of course, Big Mike is the best Boy Next Door. When I say that Walker uses her classic voice, I mean that you could easily imagine these communications as the emails or letters of Tash French or other Walker protagonists. Lucy is sweet (a bit too sweet) but smart and I liked her immediately. There's less of an edge to the characters and story of Lucy Talk than there is to most Walker books - that is probably what turned off some of her hard core fans. And some may view this as a simple Bridget Jones rip off (I didn't find it so). Ultimately, this is a very fun book - one that is easily read in small pieces, but tells a sweet and satisfying tale. Now I must get myself mentally geared up to read the one released Fiona Walker novel I haven't read (Between Males) - I expect less sweetness, and more edge with that one!