I had a good time reading this, a great bunch of characters, you get to know the supporting characters a little too and I loved myself a little bit of Ty. (Cara's best friend Jill's Brother).
I have to tell you at one point, i was that annoyed with Josh, i wanted Ty to swoop in and take Cara and runaway into the sunset with him!!! But i won't spoil.
I loved the relationship between Seth & Cara, that was a really wonderful part of the book, and more so when Zack his Dad came back. A real sense of family and community to this whole story and even the local mean girls played a part!
The relationship between Josh & Cara was sweet and sexy at times, the first kiss, the second kiss ;-)holy smokes!!! But Josh was also an Alpha male, so it is also about showing his woman how he will take care of her, worship only her and marking his ground to others that he loves her, that they are together, which is HOT to a certain extent, but I felt he took it to the extremes and his testosterone levels got way out of control and hit JERK levels. I would slapped him for some of his comments! I think he got away with some of them far too easily.
Some touching moments, beautiful visuals, a bit of drama, great friends, and I am so excited for the next book. This has set the ground for the next characters and I am beside myself for Ty!! But that is why for me it is only a 3.5, I was more in love with the secondary characters than the main ones.