Mr. Merrill's research has been thorough and his historical review of this unbuilt project is written in clear language without pretension. That is unusual in architectural writing. His selection of drawings is excellent and he makes a fairly clear sequence out of a very complex process, i.e. Louis Kahn's design explorations which were always reflective and often closely personal.
As one who has witnessed Kahn's sketch-quests close up I find this particular series very stimulating because they reveal the driving vigor behind Kahn's restless curiosity to explore. Drawing for him was a vehicle which shaped a journey into the un-preplanned and evolutionary possibilities of spatial and formal order.
And these drawings carry one along in the excitement. But they carry one, alas, to the sad fact that the whole project remains in the imagination, a realistic imagination of tangible walls and light-shaping spaces, but nevertheless still a dream of what might have been.
Most important, however, is the fact that the planning of conventual/communal architecture remained fairy static, conceptually, since the 9th century Plan of St. Gall, until two 20th century architects presented radical new options, Le Corbusier in the completed Dominican monastery of La Tourette and Louis Kahn in this design proposal for a Dominican motherhouse in Philadelphia.
I get tired of exhaustive academic discussions of unbuilt works of the Masters, but here is one that rises above intellectual clutter. The drawings are allowed largely to speak for themselves and they certainly do. A book worth having if you value original thinking.
Patrick J. Quinn, FAIA.