This excellent descriptive book takes the typical architectural view that all old buildings should be preserved as part of our heritage despite the cost and any measures to upset this view are unwanted and unwarrented developments.
Very good thumbnail sketches of long forgotten buildings bring back memories of time gone past but never recognises the fact that many old buildings reach a sell-by date and should be demolished.
The sketches and illustrations are first class if a bit fanciful on some occasions
One thing the book does not recognise is the atrocious rat infested,flea lice and bedbug infected,damp, smelly and unhygenic buildings that existed in Edinburgh e.g. Arthur street, Beaumont place,Dumbiedykes, Greenside row and many parts of Leith that were present
into the latter years of the 20 century.
To advance any community must look to the future and demolish the useless past.It is a pity the author did not recognise this.
Despite all the above this is an excellent book and the author is to be congratulated but I hope in future editions he will take a more humanist approach-it is people that count not buildings.