Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
10 of 12 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Rollicking adventure under a cloud of Conradian gloom, 3 Aug 2007
A film they used to put on in the school holidays, which suits it well, as it is both a good adventure yarn, and a story of moral courage. It is actually a very decent film, its only slight flaw is its rather excessive length. Will boys (or girls) with today's attention spans be able to wait for the thought provoking end? I'm sure some will, maybe the more literate ones. And this links nicely to the literiness of the film. Based on a typically Conradian, dour, deep journey of one man's search for honour and self worth, it gets across the obvious moralistic messages and undertones very ably, with the help of the two star actors: Two of Britain's finest: Mason and O'Toole. They play enemies here, both educated characters, and both detesting each other's moral make up. Mason is almost admirable in his honest criminality, pitted against the nauseating goodness of the noble-spirited O'Toole. Their bickering rivalry is the highlight of the film for me, with all the action and explosions of this ripping adventure, it is the war of words these two share, when they get to exchange their opinions of each other that makes the film memorable. 'You stink of piety!' sneers the unimpressed Mason, when it's clear his adversary is not one to back down from his 'mission'. The sort of film that used to be made quite often, but may seem old fashioned to some kids now. Certainly not just a kid's film though, it has more than enough depth for any adult. A darn good yarn.
ps. Eli Wallach is also in top form here as a Kurtzesque crime lord in the Asian jungle.
|
|
|
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Richard Brooks's version of Joseph Conrad, 18 April 2009
After reading Conrad's novel "Lord Jim" I was delighted to know that there was a DVD version available, and I could hardly wait for the order to arrive.
Though the film version of this novel is pleasing to watch, its screen adaptation of the novel with all the changes was a disappoinment and shock. But then how does one translate a masterpiece, with its pages of dialogue, probing into the mysteries and reality of the soul of a man, to the screen? Mr. Brooks must also have had an eye on the boxoffice and this is the result. As an adventure film for mature boys it is above average and beautifully shot, but alas it is not Conrad.
|
|
|
1 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Long, lavish and monotonous, 1 April 2008
A strangely monotonous film that conspicuously fails to do justice to the Conrad novel. The steamy Southeast Asian settings are wonderful, and the star-studded cast includes tried and tested favourites of the day such as Peter O'Toole, Jack Hawkins, Eli Wallach, Kurt Jurgens and James Mason. But somehow the film never really takes off. It's far too long, the dialogue lurches between the impenetrable and the corny, and Peter O'Toole's intense-blue-eyed-gazing-into-space routine, which served him so well in Lawrence of Arabia, irritates more than it impresses. There are some good moments, such as the scenes of the storm-tossed ship Patna, and James Mason, sporting a short-brimmed black bowler hat of antique design, is splendid to behold in the role of Gentleman Brown. In general, however, this is a dull and tedious affair. Some of the detail seems to me to have been lifted from the earlier Bridge on the River Kwai, but the direction, by Richard Brooks, lacks David Lean's magnificent grasp of wide-screen cinematography. After it came out in the mid-1960s, Lord Jim soon lapsed into obscurity, and one can quite see why.
|
|
|
|