Actually, the 'Sunday in the Park With George' poster was my first introduction to Sondeim, whilst working as a pizza boy in New York. I used to walk past it on the way to Godfather's pizza in Times Square. Never heard of him til then. The poster really caught the eye and although, sadly, I didn't have the money to see the show, I did eventually buy a cassette. I still have it today. Also, more recently, the DVD, which I watched with my daughter, back in London some twenty years or so later.
But you want to know about the book!
'Look, I Made a Hat' is as wonderful a book as the first volume. It is a pleasure, as a reader, to be in Sondheim's company and confidences. He is adept at sounding as if he is directly speaking with you, not as common a skill in writers as might be imagined. If you are interested in the thoughts and processes behind the shows it is engrossing. I felt somewhat like a young boy, making a rare visit to a favourite uncle, hanging on every word and precious opinion. Some critics have argued with Sondheim's essay on theatrical criticism and his views of other musical writers, but it's not necessary to agree with every opinion here to enjoy the book. Sondheim makes clear the openly subjective approach to the book in the extended title.
Another criticism I've read is that he is focused more on the inspiration behind the lyrics rather than the musicality. Perhaps, but I am happy to take this book for what it is rather than what it isn't. I would vote it one of the books of the year and warmly recommend buying it.
As with the first volume, the pleasure is to dip into it, tempting as it is to take a couple of days off work and read the whole lot. So far I've read through the Sunday in the Park with George, Into the Woods and Road Show sections. Enjoyable as the recent Menier Factory production of Road Show was, the songs never stayed with me. As a read , though, the chapter on the show's development was very interesting.
I also had to look up Dick Tracy, one of the few comic-based films I have ever enjoyed. Sondheim writes about Madonna singing 'Sooner Or Later'(a beautiful song) : ' I thought it might be chance to make a hit record'. Alas! Not. It did, however, bring an unfamiliar burst of passion from the pop singer. It's one of the many admirable qualities of Sondheim's songs.
Finally, as I mentioned in the first paragraph my daughter, I have to say it's quite fun reading / singing some of the lyrics aloud as bed time story material with a child. 'Agony' a particular favourite of ours.