Most Helpful Customer Reviews
9 of 9 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
hardcoded subtitles., 3 May 2011
I bought "Lola Montes: The Restored Edition [1955] [DVD]" The English subtitles are hardcoded onto the movie and also over the lower black border. These are not regular DVD subtitles (vobsub). You cannot switch them off. This is an incredibly stupid and annoying thing to do, especially on what is claimed to be a "Restored Edition", so the restoration is also something of a careless mutilation. Aside from that the picture and sound quality is quite good. The term "restored" in this case refers to lost footage which was found and reincorporated (it had been cut by the studio/distributor against the director's wishes). Don't expect the kind of flawless picture you get on some other films where "restored" refers to restoring the image and/or sound quality, as in recent restorations of North by North West, The Red Shoes, Black Narcissus etc. or you'll be sorely disappointed.
edit: I just saw some of the Criterion Collection edition of this movie. The subtitles on the Criterion edition are not hard coded. The picture is flawless. The sound is superb. It makes me realise just how *incredibly* poor this supposedly restored DVD actually is. What a rip off. Lousy print, lousy sound, stupid clumsy subtitling ruining the movie. If I could give it 0 stars I would. I've bought some really terrible DVDs of classic movies, a lot of OK or unobjectionable ones and a few that are genuinely restored to a high standard, well presented and technically excellent. This one is a genuine stinker, being so bad that it ruins the experience of simply watching and enjoying the film.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
20 of 21 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
One of the greatest films ever, 3 Feb 2005
This review is from: Lola Montes [DVD] [1955] [US Import] (DVD)
I first saw this on TV about 20 years ago, and was delighted to see that it had appeared on DVD. My memory hadn't let me down. This is an amazing film, full of stunning images, vast crowd scenes, subtle use of EastmanColour, amazing fluid camera movement, low-key naturalistic acting, and wonderful performances. Lola Montez was an 'adventuress', who, in this lightly fictionalised account of her life, has ended up in a circus, re-enacting key scenes from her life. In flashback, we see what really happended, starting with an unhappy marriage, her career as a dancer, and affairs with Liszt and the King of Bavaria (Anton Walbrook), the latter causing a revolution! Lola is played by Martine Carol, a wonderful French actress, and the ring-master in the circus scenes is a youthful Peter Ustinov. Mention must also be made of Auric's music, which captures the mood exactly. This film is truly astonishing in its lavish detail and epic flair, and I can't recommend it highly enough.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Max Ophuls' final masterpiece, 30 Mar 2010
This is one of THE great movies of all time, and the culmination of Ophuls' career, and a movie one can watch time and time again. Working in Technicolor for the first time, and with his largest ever budget, Ophuls produced a stunningly beautiful and poignant version of the scandalous career of Lola Montes, the most famous courtesan of her time, without once overstepping the bounds of immaculate good taste(to the despair of his producers who were hoping for a saucy crowd-pleaser along the line of "Caroline Cherie" with the same star).Everything about the movie, the breathtaking camera work, and marvellous design, reveals Ophuls as one of the great artists of the cinema, and this restored version enables one to guage the full extent of his artistry.Numerous scenes,notably the first flashback to the episode in the coach with Franz Liszt, and the episode of the sea voyage as a young girl, are to be seen here in fuller versions than hitherto available. Special mention must be made of Georges Auric's superb score. Extras include fascinating information on the making of the movie (initially intended for Christian-Jaque)from Ophuls' collaborators.
A DVD to treasure.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|