Rather more than a whiff of grapeshot was fired at the massed ranks of Jacobite historiography and especially that overrated Culloden by John Prebble, when this book was first published. Although successive works by this author and a few others, eg Duffy, Pollock and Oates have refined this version of the '45, the originality here is undeniable. Backed up with superb maps, plans and illustrations, the author has done a great job of investigating original sources and coming up with a new interpretation. Controversial, yes, but there is nothing wrong in that. The few shortcomings are that the book is not footnoted and I cannot recall an index. Culloden has been written about many times, but often with limited success. This book cannot be ignored, whether you agree with the thesis or not.