2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Light Speed, Gravitation and Quantum Instantaneity, 30 Jan 2010
This review is from: Light Speed, Gravitation and Quantum Instantaneity (Paperback)
This book is for those who really want to try to understand the universe and have a basic background to maths and physics roughly comparable to the UK A-level or above. Trained academic physicists will find it very hard to entertain the possibility that some of their hard-gained knowledge might be wrong....most web-discussions focus on side-tracking the ideas in this book. But unlike the normal loony-science books, this book is academically rigorous and challenges anyone to disprove any of the step-by-step mathematical proofs. I personally couldn't actually find anything wrong with the mathematics although I cannot say I agree with all the conclusions.
I am not certain yet exactly what I think of this book. It is certainly one which keeps you awake wondering where the mistakes are and then why you hadn't thought of all these arguments yourself.
The authors have not made many friends in academic circles and so their work is not as widely circulated as perhaps it could have been. Prof. Alan Winfield of UWE, UK is an exception as he has publicly stated the views are worthy of further analysis and has written the foreword.
The book starts off with a very philosophical statement of the approaches taken in physics leading up to the standard model which is generally accepted today. However as with all scientific subjects, there are always some areas which would benefit from more thorough research. There are several well-known problems with current physics. The problems are essentially that our current understanding of the world has problems at very small scales and at very large scales. There are also anomalies such as the Pioneer Anomaly which is not easy to understand using current techniques. Other problems are reconciling Gravity with other known forces.
However by re-writing some of our fundamental laws (essentially just rearranging the existing equations, not making changes to them!) the authors claim to have found some solutions to some of the major problems throughout physics. Their conclusions do not require us to believe in dark matter and multiple dimensions of the universe.
The absolutely best part is that these theories can be TESTED. Yes, there are actually experiments which could be done to prove or disprove the thesis presented....and it would be much much cheaper than the Large Hadron Collider!
So if you are interested in maths and physics with a possibility of learning something new or even like the challenge of trying to find the mistake, this book is excellent. If however you have a professional reputation to promote you will probably hide this book well away. It really is the most blasphemous scientific book I have ever seen.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No