Let me start with what I thought was brilliant about this book: There is a very strong 'narrative voice' in the shape of Grant Wiggins who is himself conflicted about his place in this plantation community. He is an educated black man in a society that expects blacks to use false grammar and submit to white supremacy without complaint. Grant wants to leave - he had already left to go to college - but he's come back, and he's not quite sure why. He's unhappy and often unjust, sometimes even selfish, and that is what is intriguing about this story.
Grant is asked to visit another black man from the community who was wrongfully sentenced to death. His task is to teach Jefferson how to be a man - and walk to his execution standing tall.
It is here that the story falls apart for me somewhat. It is a very powerful plot device but rather than fuel everything else, it seems that minor stories were created with the sole purpose of moving that main plot forward. Minor charactors pop up sporadically when they conveniently serve the main story, and that makes it somewhat unbelievable. At the same time, the actions of some of the characters seem arbitrary, and while I'm not looking to have everything neatly and logically explained to me, it also will not do to have dramatic scenes for the purpose of drama only - and then the characters fall back into their old behaviours because otherwise the main story would become difficult to handle.
Grant is the one who tells the story throughout but when Jefferson's execution arrives it changes to an omniscient narrator. That annoyed me immensely because again it felt like the author just hadn't come up with a powerful way of handling this part of the story through Grant's voice.
But it is for Grant's voice and his story that I'm giving this book four stars. Grant's story doesn't leave you with a nice solution but that is what makes it moving. The storyline around the execution isn't strong but if you can ignore that you have a really good book. I'll say: read it.