1957's Les Girls is a pretty mediocre movie musical send-off for Cole Porter, and for Gene Kelly too for that matter, here taking his last lead in an MGM musical. It's never outright bad, just never really good enough, with most of the musical numbers limited to the stage routines performed by Kelly, Kay Kendall, Mitzi Gaynor and Taina Elg rather than bursting out into the `real' world - which is a little bit ironic since it's a film about truth and reality, with Elg suing Kendall over her memoirs leading to three different versions of the romantic complications that lead to the act's demise. Yes, it's Rashomon, the Musical, but with even more plotholes - the whole thing depends on the characters not talking to each other for years after one dramatic event, leading to misunderstandings and misinterpretations that end up in the Old Bailey. Unfortunately the script is never sharp enough, George Cukor's direction never able to compensate quite enough and most of the songs not that memorable - only the comic Ladies in Waiting and Gene Kelly's uncredited choreography in Why Am I So Gone About That Gal? have much life to them: elsewhere it's more a comedy with the odd song thrown in rather than an all-out musical. While Taina Elg is the film's weakest link (though an inspid Jacques Bergerac runs her close as her bland romantic interest), Kay Kendall steals the acting honors, though in retrospect there's something rather uncomfortable about her starring in a film where one character lies about a fake illness while her lover and doctor in real life were lying to her about her very real terminal one. Leslie Philips and Patrick MacNee pop up in supporting roles and it's lavishly produced, but while the spark hasn't completely left the MGM musical at this late stage, the light is definitely flickering its last here. Still, Gene Allen and William A. Horning's art direction is fairly impressive - but you know what they say about shows where you come out humming the sets...
WHV's Region 1 NTSC DVD boasts a good widescreen transfer preserving the original CinemaScope aspect ratio, featurette Cole Porter in Hollywood - Ca C'est L'Amour, cartoon Flea Circus and the original trailer.