I chatted with David Rohl about his ideas at a conference and decided to further explore his theories. I found "Legend" challenging but rewarding, forming key points for David's `Eden to Exile'. David does provide a sound preface and introduction and cleverly summarizes each section to help ensure you are picking up key messages as you journey through. Approximately 500 pages of small print delving into the world of archeology and linguistics make for heavy weather to the uninitiated. There are about 80 black and white photographs and 90 illustrations to complement the written word.
David gives praise to Reginald Arthur Walker, (1917-1989), who was the source of the concept and skeleton that David has built on. The general outline of Mr. Rohl's ideas are the location of Eden is identified, described and explored. Dates are put to prehistoric events such as the great flood. Key figures from Genesis such as Noah are identified from other sources and a strong case put forward that these ancient heroes have a common source. Due respect is also given to the German Werner Papke who links Sumerian Gods with constellations' and proposes Nimrod and Cush of Genesis are also in Sumerian legend.
I imagine several readers would be critical of David's speculation of events that may have occurred in or around 4000 B.C. The writer gives his argument and provides the reader with evidence, referenced for you to check out. The interpretation of the `facts' is key to everything, especially the time-line of events. The conclusion is history needs a rewrite based on his revised chronology.
The descendents of figures from Genesis, such Noah, Nimrod and Gilgalmesh are tracked from Eden to Egypt where they enter as `boat people'. About half the book leads you up to the beginnings of the Egyptian civilization. The remaining half traces Egyptian architecture, symbols and key figures back to the speculated Eden beginnings.
David produced a scholarly work and this should be considered at the point of `purchase'. Readers' fresh to David's style and format may find it academic. My opinion is David's work would benefit from a series of documentary programmes aired on terrestrial TV exploring his works and challenging his ideas, arguments and evidence presented. The complex nature of the subject could be presented in documentary format in manageable chunks. I would recommend this work to Bible scholars and those with an interest in Egyptology. For those David Rohl readers who would like to explore further try `From Eden to Exile: The epic history of the people of the bible'.