Amazon.co.uk Review
Hope of the States were, when they first appeared in 2003, a very serviceable idea. Post-millennial tension, post-rock crescendos and palatable anthemic twists that made them seem a post-Coldplay certainty, in better jackets. Debut album The Lost Riots was very nearly great, let down only by some superfluous ambition they didnt quite have the muscle to realise and Sam Herlihys trying vocal. But with Left its surprising to find them addressing their previous weaknesses with such wilful gusto.
Limitations remain, not least the intended anarchism of Sams lyrics seeming more pub-stool than pulpit-reactionary (see "This Is A Question"), but his causes begin to find their bulls-eyes on "Industry" and "Forwardirektion". And thats not to mention his inflating vocals holding court convincingly on the twinkling, sombre and eventually chest-beating "The Good Fight". Overall tracks are trimmer and more focussed without sacrificing the sure climb to the climax with a mystical staff that made them so engaging in the first place.
The spectre of Radioheads, and particularly Johnny Greenwoods, influence hangs as heavy over this album as the last, especially on the cross-fire guitar of "Bonfires". And Sigur Ros producer Ken Thomas adds his expectedly fertile touch, providing their songs with the epic backdrop they need if theyre to succeed just bathe in the cosmos of sound on "The Church Choir". Their debut left us asking whether to be on the cusp of greatness is any better than being an acre away from it. They just moved a step closer to that not being their concern. --James Berry
CD Description
The second album from Hope Of The States, 'Left' is the follow up to the 2004 debut 'The Lost Riots'. Whilst keeping their distinctive sound, their new direction brings a more accessible, song-based record. Produced by Ken Thomas (Terrorvision, Sigur Ros), 'Left' includes the single 'Sing It Out'.