Exactly what I expected: songs more lean than those of Tindersticks, the voice carrying the tune with less of a musical complexity to cushion or sustain that memorably melancholy voice. Since I favor the first three Tindersticks studio CDs over their later soul-influenced period, this album did surprise me a bit. It tends to remind you of the janglier, chillier period of Stuart's band, as they were over a decade ago now on record. The approach here's similar, although the songs do not take as long to swirl. On the solo album, the music's slightly less dense, and the tunes--while they don't rush, certainly--being under the vocals rather than accompanying the voice and amplifying it with ambitious arrangements--do not wear out their welcome. Lyrics show intelligence and care in their craft. It's not a long album, and the ten songs are better for it by such economy.
Maria McKee and Lhasa de Sela each duet with Staples, and the results are about the same as past pairings: the added tension and call-and-response dialogue established makes Stuart's character in these songs more dramatic, without straining too hard for emotional impact. Female vocals that he can play off against often have worked to his credit in the past, and here Lhasa's contribution to "Leaving" enriches the song; the arrangement's greater density makes it one of the standout tracks, next to the drama McKee confidently offers on "Way," and the stretch of the epic opening song. His delivery, this solo effort seems to tell us, is as it is, and there's no drastic departures from his signature sound here. He knows when to project and when to refrain, and this judgment makes a consistent album.
Fans of the first Tindersticks phase, like me, will not find the orchestral depth (except perhaps on the first track and some of the track with Lhasa), but the voice and the attitudes it conveys, somehow managing to avoid being maudlin, are in fine form. I wish more songs were like the opener, as the added textures blend well with the vocals. But, this would be to want a Tindersticks rather than a solo album, I admit. There is a slight danger in sameness, as this album's pretty much the same mood and pace. It'll fit your pensive moments. As long as you do not expect quite the detail given by his band but more of his vocals as foregrounded than the subtly shaded music, this will please you.