That was, to be perfectly frank, my initial response when I learned that Dave de Bronkart--widely known on the Internet as e-Patient Dave--was publishing a book about his battle with stage IV kidney cancer. I mean, sure, I've read my share of cancer-survival stories, but in this case I figured I already knew the story. Dave de Bronkart is all over YouTube, and he tells the story quite frequently: how his doctors discovered his cancer, what his initial research told him about the cancer, Danny Sands giving him the prescription for ACOR. It's all out there. Go ahead and look it up. Dave's a charming speaker, and hearing him tell his tale won't affect your reading of the book. You should listen to Dave's talks, and then you should buy this book.
First, you should buy this book because it's not just a cancer survival story or even just a cancer survival how-to book. Laugh, Sing, and Eat Like a Pig is a book on patient empowerment, on why and how to take control of your life, even in the face of personal tragedy. You don't have to have cancer or know someone with cancer to get a lot out of this book.
Second, I loved the book. I'm still loving the book on the second read, and I usually don't re-read anything. I think grad school did that to me. I had so much to read, so much to translate, and so much to analyze that I never wanted to read anything again unless it was absolutely necessary. Every book I re-read is time stolen from one more new book I could be reading. Still, I've really enjoyed Dave's book. I love the way it bounces in and out of chronological sequence. I love the asides and insertions. The format, with its four-dimensional look at Dave's experience and the experience of cancer in general, reminds me of John Brunner's experimental science fiction novels Stand on Zanzibar and The Sheep Look Up. Sorry, that's the English major in me taking over the conversation and dragging it off on another tangent.
Now, not everyone who reads this book loves it. Some, recently, have argued that Dave, like many other cancer survivors, puts the onus of survival on the cancer sufferer. They think he's blaming the dying, accusing them of weakness of will, or faith, or chutzpaph. Yes, I admit that I, too, had that impression. At the beginning. Occasionally, Dave does interject that he had decided to live, does say he decided that he wouldn't accept sub-par care. It's easy to read that kind of didactic mode as "anyone who dies must have either accepted the death or accepted sub-par care."
Easy, but false.
Yes, Dave gives advice based on his own experiences, and doing the opposite of what he suggests just might have lost many lives. Talk to Regina Holliday. Her husband received sub-par care, and I don't think he realized as much until it was too late to matter. Dave also discusses his own fears and sorrows in facing impending death. He knows his attitude alone wasn't going to save his life. He admits that while he hoped for full recovery, he knew the dark other possibility was still looming. My grandfather succumbed to cancer, and while he was still lucid, even he said you can never give in to something like that. When the HDIL-2 begins to work, Dave rejoices in being one of the lucky 20%. I don't think it's fair to condemn his rejoicing in his own survival. Yes, 80% do not have Dave's luck, but that tragedy is not Dave's fault. I would add to that bit of luck with the HDIL-2 a reminder that Dave's cancer was found early, almost by accident. The x-ray that discovered a metastasis in his lung was for a shoulder injury. If not for that shoulder x-ray, it's hard to say exactly when Dave would have found out about his cancer. Would the weeks it took for the pains to start also have been enough to slash his survival chances? Surely. How much? I doubt anyone could say with any certainty.
So, read the book. Whether you have cancer and need a little advice or don't have cancer and need a little help dealing with the modern medical instrumentality or just want a good book to read, read the book. You won't regret it.