- Actors: Ian Hart, Rosana Pastor, Icíar Bollaín, Tom Gilroy, Marc Martínez
- Directors: Ken Loach
- Writers: Jim Allen
- Producers: Gerardo Herrero, Marta Esteban, Rebecca O'Brien, Sally Hibbin, Ulrich Felsberg
- Language Catalan, English, Spanish
- Classification: 15
- Studio: Artificial Eye
- VHS Release Date: 28 Oct 1996
- Run Time: 109 minutes
- Average Customer Review: 4.6 out of 5 stars See all reviews (14 customer reviews)
- ASIN: B00004CRXW
- Amazon Bestsellers Rank: 9,884 in Video (See Top 100 in Video)
|
||||||||||||||
|
||||||||||||||
|
||||||||||||||
Product details |
Tags Customers Associate with This Product(What's this?)Click on a tag to find related items, discussions, and people.
|
Customer Reviews
Most Helpful Customer Reviews
107 of 113 people found the following review helpful
Format:DVD
Ken Loach's film Land and Freedom is a moving portrayal of a small POUM (United Marxist Worker's Party) militia fighting in the Spanish Civil War in the late 1930s. Its protagonist, David, travels from Liverpool to join in the fight against Fascism. He falls for a militiawoman, and finds that the Communist ideals he stands for are false.
Loach does a superb job of showing an almost forgotton faction of the fight against Franco. The POUM were denounced as traitors by the main (Russian controlled) Communist Party, and forced to disband, their leaders arrested. The film has been criticised for its narrow focus on the small militia, but that is what makes it so wonderful - it is possible to engage with the characters and feel what they feel. We may see little of the Anarchists or the Communist Popular Army, or even of the enemy Nationalists, but we understand what the war is about.
Loach wanted to show how the Communists betrayed the ideals of the Left in the Spanish Civil War. They said the war must be won before revolution can happen. Understandably, David, a proud member of the Communist Party in the UK, refuses to believe that they could want anything other than revolution - isn't that what Communism is all about? He soon comes to realise, that with Stalin in control of the Spanish Communists and ultimately the whole Spanish Left, there will never be a revolution: Stalin is too interested in forging ties with the West to embarrass himself with a social revolution.
This film is incredible. Some understanding of the Spanish Civil War and its many complicated parties and militias would help, but even so it is enjoyable and very moving. Anyone who has read George Orwell's "Homage to Catalonia" should watch this. David is much more idealistic and naive than Orwell, but it is the same fight on the same side, with the same pain at defeat. I would recommend this film to anyone, it is wonderfully filmed, with an international cast, not even all professional actors. The story is framed by episodes in present day England, following David's death. As his grand-daughter finds his old letters and newspaper cuttings, we see that although there is a difference of sixty years, the fight of the Spanish Civil War is still going on everywhere, it is still relevant.
29 of 32 people found the following review helpful
Format:VHS Tape
This outstanding film offers a fascinatoing insight into the Spanish Civil war through the eyes of a young British volunteer, memorably portrayed by Ian Hart. Following his death in present-day Britain, his grand-daughter sorts through an old suitcase containing the mementos of his time in war-torn Spain, providing the framework for the story. Brilliantly directed by Ken Loach, the film is a poignant evocation of that same mix of beauty and ugliness, love and tragedy that other writers on Spain have portrayed, and which all those who have, in different ways, been captivated by that coutnry will instantly recognise. The use of loosely-scripted dialogue to add spontaneity and immediacy is particularly effective. Altogether an unforgettable experience.
28 of 32 people found the following review helpful
Format:VHS Tape
This is indeed an excellent film. Ken Loach's characteristic combination of gritty subject matter handled with great sensitivity gives the film a great poignancy. It is particularly fascinating for its treatment of the young hero's struggles with idealism and disillusionment. I couldn't watch this film without thinking of George Orwell's "A Homage to Catalonia" (his account of his experiences of fighting in the Spanish Civil War). The similarities between Orwell's book and Loach's film are too numerous and significant to be co-incidence; I'm sure Loach acknowledges this somewhere, but I saw the film some time ago and don't yet own a copy. Highly recommended to anyone with an interest in Loach, Orwell, the ideology of Socialism, the fight against Fascism, and overall memorable, thought provoking films!
Would you like to see more reviews about this item?
Were these reviews helpful?
Let us know
Most Recent Customer Reviews
land and freedom
Excellent informative movie. a real eye opener. anyone interested in spain should watch this, also read george orwells "Homage to Catalonia" or Laurie Lees "A moment of War".
Published 9 months ago by christine.graville
Facinating, touching complex, film
This is a very important film to be seen, from a legendary important challenging film director, Mr Ken Loach, who never holds back on issues which need to be discussed. Read more
Published on 30 Mar 2010 by Franz Kiffka
Remarkable film
"Land and Freedom" is a fictional story set in Spain, 1936-37, but with 'flashforwards' to present-day England. Read more
Published on 23 Jan 2010 by Eric Johnston
A timeless tale of war and division from 1930's Spain which opened my...
Celebrated socialist filmmaker Ken Loach ("Kes" & "Riff-Raff") in his final collaboration with screenwriter Jim Allen ("Hidden Agenda" & "Raining Stones") heads to Spain for this... Read more
Published on 4 Dec 2009 by Mutt
A brief introduction
A great movie and an interesting portrail of one mans involvement in the Spanish Civil war. As with many of Ken Loach movies this one has the feel of reality about it. Read more
Published on 12 Nov 2009 by Gordon Thomson
unconvincing
Despite all the good reviews. I simply found this film unconvincing. There are some excellent scenes, but as a whole it lacks the feeling of conviction from the actors. Read more
Published on 15 Jun 2009 by Mr. John Lumbard
Disappointing judged as a film rather than animated history
I'm at odds with the other reviewers here. I'd prefer to review it as a wartime and/or political drama rather than as a piece of non-fiction, which seems to be more the yardstick... Read more
Published on 11 April 2009 by Humpty Dumpty
masterpiece
this film brilliantly illustrates why an hopelessy ideologically fragmented republican movement handed franco victory on a plate. Read more
Published on 2 Dec 2007 by David Perry
Best Ken Loach film in ages
I have quite an ambivalent attitude to much of Ken Loach's work. Some of his films, like Kes, are superb. Read more
Published on 1 Jun 2007 by Donaldo
The films still talks to us but not the historical situation
With the time that has elapsed since the Spanish Civil War and the time that has also elapsed since this film came out, 1995, this film has probably completely changed in meaning... Read more
Published on 14 May 2006 by Jacques COULARDEAU
Customer Discussions
|
This product's forum
Active discussions in related forums
Search Customer Discussions
|
Related forums
|
Listmania!
Look for similar items by subject
Feedback
- Would you like to update product info or give feedback on images?
|
