Well I know I'm going to get vilified over this but I think this Version is lackluster,filmed incorrectly (too many close ups-if you cannot see the feet how can you know whats going on)and the wrong choice for Male lead.Carlos Acosta is a fine dancer,but his needs fall into the category distant to this production,he needs powerful parts to show what he is best at.
Marianela Nunez/LISE on the other hand dances beautifully,She is the right choice for this ballet,she has grace to match her beauty-but where is the magic ! She and Acosta just don't have it, (Lesley Collier and Michael Coleman certainly did)and I'm sorry to say that spoilt the whole show for me.
William Tuckett made a pleasing Simone,but sadly was not really convincing in his role,the corps de ballet were fine which did give a lift to the play,as were the Rooster and Hens(better in this than the earlier presentation) and as usual the Orchestra of the ROH was as close to perfection as is possible.
The scenery was fine,giving that Rural effect required,and the audience were well behaved and generous with their applause.
So what to do about buying it,well if you can afford both that's what you should do,if not I recommend that you buy the Collier /Coleman performance that one has the magic,with the little smiles and kisses,and the comedy element,which keeps it ahead of this presentation by a long way.